This is more about cleaning than protecting. I don't think UV is an issue. I find that adding a protectanc like 303 make it easier to keep clean. So the question is, does Magic Eraser remove or damage any of the outer layers of good quality marine grade vinyl? If it does, it should not be used.
Of course, the harsher the cleaner, the better it will clean but also do more damage to the vinyl. There are people who swear by soft scrub. It has bleach and and abrasive in it. It easily cleans and bleaches white vinyl but is it damaging the vinyl. I think it's important to apply a protectant any time you clean vinyl with anything other than mild soap and water.