Vovo vs. Merc's

surefix

Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2007
RO Number
25171
Messages
2
I am considering a pre-owned 1999-2002 27ft Formula PC. The two boats I'm looking at have different engines. One has Merc's and the other has Volvo Penta's. Any pro and cons for either engine?
 
In that year range, I'd go with the Volvos. Honestly, I'd go with the Volvos all the time, but that's like the Ford vs Chevy truck debate.

The reason I say especially in those years is because the BIIIs had problems (I assume this boat has those) with corrosion. It was corrected around 2000-2001 I believe, but I just steer clear. I've had both, and have liked my VPs better.
 
Specifics-What size engine in each, are they singles or twins and what drive on each. Prior maintenance also matters. Thx.
 
All things being equal most of the people on this forum will tell you that Volvo is the superior engine/outdrive. We have had this Volvo/Merc debate many times here on Boatered and I would say it is usually about 4 to 1, Volvo over Merc.
But as Liquid Diet say, maintainance is also an important consideration.

If you are in salt water, I would say it is a no brainer that Volvo is the only way to go if you want a boat with outdrives.
 
yep.. in salt water volvo is the no brainer. while my experience was with the older duoprop vs newer merc inboard, i'll never buy a merc powered boat again. merc. has a history often serious issues like the B3 corrosion, sinking boats in case of below failure, massive failures on it's Vee drives around 98/00, etc... the inboards i had (98 7.4s) had plastic raw water pump installed in such a way that you had to pull the pump and it's hoses to replace the impeller.
 
But make sure there are qualified VP repair facilities nearby. VP has fewer qualified technisions and parts availability in some parts of the country.
 
Do me a favor and please don't ever ask the Volvo/Merc question. I know you are new to the forum and are likely unaware of how much this topic has been beaten to death. The same people with the same rant every time. Buy what you want. And if you're looking for a really great price on a clean freshwater 2000 27 PC, let me know. My friend is upgrading and looking to sell.

deadhorse.gif
 
Come on Jason, give him a break. As you stated, he's new to the forum. He asked an honest newbie question. He's not trying to stir anybody up, just wants peoples' opinions so he can make a more informed decision. He doesn't know what he wants as he doesn't know what's better. If you don't want read the answers, don't look at the topic. If he assked what was better Brand X or Cruisers, you'd have an answer for him I'm sure.
 
Okay, you want an answer to the question? Either one will be fine. Merc power seems to cost more on certain boats, and Volvo is a good name with great reliability. Come to think of it, both are reliable. Volvo offers great warranties and backs them up very well, although most likely a boat of that vintage wouldn't have a factory warranty remaining. Bravo 3's can corrode if you don't use the proper anodes for your environment, as do Volvo drives. So if you maintain them well, each one would be fine.

People's opinions are biased, just remember that. Buy what you want, and decide for yourself if you'd buy another one or not.
 
The Merc corrosion issue was instigated in late 1998 by the omission of the carrier bearing anode behind the props on the B3 when they redesigned the lower housing. What made it an infamous legend was Mercury's insistence that there was NO problem. And they stood behind that claim for a couple of years...meanwhile covering something like 500,000 drives and trying to sweep it under the rug.

Don't be put off by a Merc drive. There is a retrofit prop anode now made for the pre-2002 drives when they corrected the problem with the addition of a couple of anodes, 1 for the prop, a secondary anode for the ventilation plate. Maintain your anodes and check the hull continuity frequently and you have no problem.

Merc's supply and distribution line is better across the country for parts...this website is sponsored by BoatFix, who is the largest Merc distributor in the country. Keep that in mind.

Personally, I'm not into Swedish crap..;)..but that's just me stirring the pot. Volvo has a tried and true marine setup.
 
The boat has only 130 hours on the volvo and the drives are volvo as well.
quote:

Originally posted by Liquid Diet 2

Specifics-What size engine in each, are they singles or twins and what drive on each. Prior maintenance also matters. Thx.




 
That's better Jason. After all, that's what this forum is about. It's kinda of like when I get a new student, there are just some questions I get tired of answering but how else are the going to learn?
Greg
 
I agree. I guess it's just like an old hat for those of us that have been on this board the last 4 - 5 years, as you know it's been talked about so much, but new RO's don't know that so we need to give them the chance to ask their questions.

Personally, I've always had Merc power and never had any trouble with it. My new boat has Crusaders, so I no longer fit into the Merc or Volvo families. Heck, I ven had an OMC I/O years ago. Never again.
 
surefix, you need a little more education about engines and drives. The engines in either of those boats are built by GM (General Motors) They are bought by marine companies, Volvo Penta, Mercruiser, et al, and marinized. Both Merc and Volvo then add their outdrives. Here is an example of what I think the VP might have- twin 5.7 liter engines (350 ci) hopefully fuel injected, mated to their DuoProp drive. Merc might be same 5.7 liter but mated to a Bravo III. That's what I meant by specifics. Some 27 foot Formulas might have twin 4.3 liter engines (6 cylinder). Hope this helps you.
 
All things being equal, go with the Volvo's - they are MUCH better than Mercs!
 
Volvo, Volvo, Volvo! Ok! I guess you know where I stand, their Ocean Series Drives are Great and their engines are first rate.

SeaQuest OE
Anchored at Rum Cay enjoying the warm Caribbean waters and the Sun (85F today)
 
jason

i don't know what your problem is but call replies to an honest questions rants !

my facts are not rants...

ave you heard of boats sinking because of bellow failures on Mercrsuisers ? now ask the same question with Volvos... different answer isn't it. is it a rant to say that 25 years ago volvos had figured out that if you put a good set of seals in the bellhousing and a zerc fitting to grease the bearings, water will not get in the boat if the bellow fails ? it's not a rant, it's fact.

is it a fact that to replace the raw water impeller on a recent 7.4 housing you need to pull the pumps and the belt ? and that the pump is plastic ? and that with the hoses coming from behind, you can't get to the clamp and usually are better off disconnecting the hoses on the other hand and then thread them thru ? it's fact. whereas 25 years ago, volvo was already using normal raw water pump with a simple cover...

how about having to haul out th eboat to replace the impeller on earlier merc outdrives, is that rant or fact ?

i don't whow's ranting here... but it sure aint me.

although as Liz mentioned, service and parts maybe a little harder to find in some areas...

another fact, not a rant.
 
Pascal,
Responses from 5 other RO's before my response, and you automatically assume I am talking about you "ranting?" Does that tell you something?

booty.gif
 
well, next time, quote the posts you are replying to ! that will eliminate any confusion since you replied almost immediately after my post.
 
Back
Top