What, no radar?

jodon2

Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2006
RO Number
21899
Messages
373
NEW YORK - A watery crash off the coast of Brooklyn that killed two passengers and injured two was caused when a 24-foot boat ran into a tow cable between a barge and tugboat, the U.S. Coast Guard said.

The boat apparently ignored the tug's warning blasts from its horn and its light shining on the cable, which was more than 1,500 feet long, a U.S. Coast Guard official said Sunday.

The boat collided with the tow line and capsized, spilling its passengers into the dark waters of the Ambrose Channel, the busy shipping lane in Lower New York Bay, the official said.

"The tug captain took his main light and shone it on the cable and the barge. He lit it up for him,'' said Robert Laura, a chief petty officer with the U.S. Coast Guard. "The small boat got caught on the cable. That flipped him over.''

A 61-year-old man was rescued by a passing fishing vessel, and a 46-year-old man was pulled from under the capsized boat by police scuba divers, the U.S. Coast Guard said. Both were listed in stable condition at area hospitals. Their names were not released, but officials said they were New Jersey residents.

John Isello, 43, of Hasbrouck Heights, N.J., and Robert Chacon, 47, of Saddle Brook, N.J., were also pulled from the waters by divers, police said. Chacon was pronounced dead at the scene, and Isello was airlifted to nearby Floyd Bennett Field, where he was pronounced dead.

The accident occurred about 11:30 p.m. on Saturday, the police said. The
tug sent out a distress call on the radio.

A boat in the area, the Capt. Dave, piloted by David Paris, 57, of Brooklyn, responded to the call and rescued a survivor of the capsized craft.

"It was pitch black, but we found the boat,'' Paris said.

The U.S. Coast Guard was continuing to investigate the crash. No charges were filed Sunday.
 
it helps to know the meaning of the lights shown on the stern of a tug !
 
Radar won't do you much good when you go between a tug and the barge that it is towing.
 
About a month ago I was out of Barnegat inlet fishing about 6 miles out and noticed an ocean going tug towing a barge about about another mile out. The tow cable had to be at least 1/4 mile long. Could not see the cable in the water between the two. Could only see cable from aft of tug and bow of barge going into the water. Maybe operator of small boat thought it was two seperate ships.
 
"Maybe operator of small boat thought it was two seperate ships."

this is why it helps to know lights and shapes...
 
I just want to know why he was out in a 24fter in 4-6's at 11:30pm? Like I said in another post. Its taught in all the classes I've taken, including my captain's liscense class for my masters. The tug captain even lit up the cable to warn the guy and blasted his horn. Its a darn shame it happened. I wouldn't wish something like that on my worst enemy...I find it amazing though, that the buddy of one of the guys that died was able to hold onto the guy until the CG showed up.
 
Why is a tow cable so long, anyway? I can understand a few hundred feet, but 1/4 mile?
 
Those cables are always that long as far as I know. Its needed in the event that there are heavy seas and prevents the tug from being "yanked around by the barge". The longer the rope in open seas the less chance there is of this happening. The longer rope also allows for better control in open seas at faster speeds. Think about it on our level if we were to tow someone. You need a shorter rope to maneuver through inlets at slower speeds when towing but once you have the space to speed up you need a longer rope so the boat you are towing doesn't by chance end up in your stern. The bigger the tow in relation to the towing vessel the longer the rope needs to be.
 
Yep, the longer tow line allows for more catenary (droop) in the line, which allows for better shock absorption and less chance of the tow severely tugging at the tug (and subsequently, parting the line). There's also less stress on the towline and better handling of the tow. Most tows heading up Ambrose will begin to shorten when approaching the Narrows and many will take their barge alongside at this point.

The point is that no matter where this was or how long the wire was strung out, the failure of the boater to recognize the significance of the lights of the tug AND barge, the failure to maintain a radio watch, and the failure to proceed as a safe speed is what caused this accident.

Kudos to the tug crew for watching "behind their backs" and doing the best they could to prevent this.
 
Tow boats pull a tow by the weight of the towing hawser (cable), not by direclty pulling on the tow. You need a long hawser to keep it in the water. Otherwise, you get shock loading on the hawser when it snaps taught, likely leading to a parted line. Heavier loads and heavier seas both necessitate longer hawsers.

Brett
 
Back
Top