What the Fluke?

jodon2

Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2006
RO Number
21899
Messages
373
NEPTUNE - This is a fish tale about the fluke that didn't get away and the record that did.

A Neptune nurse caught the world's largest summer flounder by rod and reel off the Monmouth County coast last month.

However, the International Game Fish Association disqualified the 24.3-pound catch because Monica Oswald said she had temporarily rested her pole on the rail of her boat.

That violates IGFA rules.

It took Oswald 20 minutes to reel in the 38.2 inch doormat. She took it to an IGFA
certified weigh station and stuck it in a cooler in her garage. There it was partially eaten, most likely by a raccoon.

Oswald passed a lie-detector test about the fish.

However, IGFA world records coordinator Rebecca Wright tells The Star Ledger of Newark rules are rules. Wright says it's sad because everything else with the catch was fine.

The record of 22.7 pounds, caught by a Long Island charter captain in 1975, stands
 
That's just stupid that she got disqualified on a technicality. What is this, golf?
 
Bob,

Rules are rules. How can you play the game if everyone doesn't play by the same rules.

Atleast they didn't have to test her for steroids!!!

Jonathan
 
That's some catch ! 11# is the best I've seen. To bad about the record !!
 
It just sorta bugs me that some sports stick to every letter of the rule, such as golf and apparently fishing, but others do not. Ever see a second baseman miss the bag on a double play ball? Ever see a basketball player palm the ball when dribbling or take like 3 steps on a layup? Ever see more than 5 skaters on the ice at time in hockey?

Oh, my, but lean your fishing pole on the gunnel, or accidentally move your ball marker on the green before placing your ball, and FORGET IT.
 
I think it's kind of cool that a sport depends on the honor system.
 
Bob,
You probably haven't noticed but there is a lot of money and competition involved in "sports" today, including fishing. You might have noticed that some people can be trusted and others cheat. When you add money to any equation it can and does bring out the bad in many people. The rules are there to level the playing field. I'm sure a number of the RO's here who fish a lot have at some point caught a IGFA line class record fish, but because they know the rules they did NOT turn it in since they might have had to fudge on the rules answer.....I have caught at least one such fish. Not having your name at the top does not in any way diminish the catch.
 
This was real local for me - she had the fish weighed in at the tackle shop around the corner from my summer home. This particular fish was controversial right from the get go - she didn't leave it in the freezer of the tackle shop after the initial weigh-in to have it verified by the IGFA. Then, after she brought it home either a dog or raccoon ate most of it. It seems there were marks on it that lead some to believe that it wasn't caught with a rod & reel. She volunteered the fact that she rested her rod on the gunnel and given all the controversy, the IGFA folks probably took that as a reason to disqualify the fish. It should be pointed out that she did pass a lie-detector test and will win a $50,000 boat package from one of the local fishing magazines.
 
Yes, Bill, I have noticed that there is a lot of money in "sports" today. As a matter of fact, there's money in baseball, basketball, hockey, fishing, golf - all of them! My beef is, why are some sports so rigid with the rules, and some are not?

For example, I was watching the Phillies game last night, and Chase Utley totally missed touching the bag on a double play. Didn't matter, he was "in the vicinity" - a "rule" that is followed yet is NOT on the books. Then, a few innings later, the Phillies pitcher (can't remember which one - they used a bunch of them last night) licked his finger and then immediately wiped it off on his pants just after throwing a pitch. THAT was a no-no, and he was penalized a ball to the batter. Why is THAT rule so enforced, but not one of the most basic ones, like touching the bag?

I wonder why in fishing, it's perfectly legal to use thousands of dollars in electronics, but heaven forbid you lean the rod on the gunnel to scratch yourself or something - THAT'S apparently an unfair advantage.
 
So, if you are so upset about it Bob. Instead of criticizing those who uphold the honor of the sport, why don't you aim that passion of your at all the slackers? Seems like you can't see one side of the coin for the other. Gee, that's new.
 
Well Bob, first the "electronics" are not "catching" the fish. Second nothing was being said about it being "legal". Third, The IGFA record book listing's have pretty simple rules in place to help insure the each person lands the catch using equal tools during the fight. There usually are no ref's in fishing and we must depend on character. It works most of the time. Maybe the lady in the story above knew she broke the rules, but had the character to admit it. However, greed and ego can be very ugly. I can not tell you why some people have a strong character and others don't. If you're one of those (note word "if") that always whines about things being "unfair", well......
 
Well, this seems to be a very nice outcome. There were many questions about the "new world record". This finding allows the angler to retain the pride of the catch; elevates the sportsmanship of the sport; while not having to directly deal with the fact that this angler was trying to Bamboozle the general public.
 
Who's upset? Who's whining? I'm just noting how interesting it is that some sports are very rigid with their rules, and some are not, and it doesn't seem to be related to the amount of money involved. And Bill, when I said "legal" I meant "in line with the rules of submitting the fish for the record books in the eyes of IGFA". Sorry that I was not clear on that point. Additionally, stepping on the bag in baseball IS paramount to making the out, yet that rule is not enforced. And you have got to be kidding me by implying that the electronics don't help a fisherman catch a fish!

By the way, I do have a strong character. I am an avid hunter, and there are no "referees" out there (maybe a game warden or two, but they don't go anywhere near as far into the woods as I go). While it would be easy for me to "cheat" and take an illegal deer, or even take a shot at a legal deer that I knew wouldn't be a quick kill, I don't do that. Also, I'm the kind of guy that tells a cashier when I've been given the wrong change, I don't throw trash out my car (or boat) window, and I don't take things that aren't mine. These strong character traits are important, especially when there are 6 and 10 year old eyes and ears watching everything you do! Setting an example is an important thing.

Finally, if Ms. Oswald knew that she violated the rules and had the character to admit it, then why was the IGFA even involved? If this was the case, then she probably would have snapped a few photos, taken the fish home and had it for dinner. But she didn't, she took it to an "IGFA certified weigh station", which implies that she was trying to get into the record books, despite knowing she violated the rules. This tells me she does not have the strong character to which you refer.
 
I know I'll catch some flak, but I'm with Bob on this one. I don't know anything about fishing, but the rule seems silly. From what little I've seen, it seems strapping yourself into a fighting chair and wearing all sorts of gear that basically helps you hang onto the rod is ok, but you can't rest the rod against the side of the boat. Puhhhleease.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Finally, if Ms. Oswald knew that she violated the rules and had the character to admit it, then why was the IGFA even involved? If this was the case, then she probably would have snapped a few photos, taken the fish home and had it for dinner. But she didn't, she took it to an "IGFA certified weigh station", which implies that she was trying to get into the record books, despite knowing she violated the rules. This tells me she does not have the strong character to which you refer.






Bob you are assuming that she knew about this one particular rule.

I doubt she did know about it.

They probably asked her to describe the way whe caught the fish, she probably told them step by step, not knowing that if you put the rod down the fish will not count.

Jonathan
 
Bob, finding fish is not catching fish. Finding game is not harvesting game. I doubt you think harvesting a deer with a rifle, shotgun, crossbow, or bow are all the same. Do you scout for sign before hunting or do you use any tools such as trail cam's, infra-red game finders, gps, topo maps, aerial photo's, to help locate your game? I doubt you just walk in the woods and sit down. Should the Pope and Young or Boone and Crockett record books have no rules on the harvest? The IGFA record book is about the "catching" not the finding.

I have no idea about Ms. Oswald and her character or her motives. You are the one who complained about the "rules". You are the one who feels the need to write a long statement about your own character. You claim, "I'm just noting how interesting it is that some sports are very rigid with their rules, and some are not.", yet you made this statement, "That's just stupid that she got disqualified on a technicality". By that a person could reasonably think you feel killing a trophy game animal a couple of minutes after or before legal shooting time is just a "technicality" and it should go in the book, regardless of how many other people never took the same type of shoot because of the "technicality".
 
No, shooting a deer after or before legal shooting time is not an advantage, it's a safety issue. I don't see the advantage or safety issue of leaning the rod on the gunnel, therefore, I see it as a stupid technicality.
 
Oh some arbitrary time is not a "technicality" even though it has no base on weather conditions, scope quaility or even open sights, availible light, and field conditions. All of these are the real safety issue's and are based on personal judgement at the time.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

No, shooting a deer after or before legal shooting time is not an advantage, it's a safety issue. I don't see the advantage or safety issue of leaning the rod on the gunnel, therefore, I see it as a stupid technicality.






Placing the rod in a rod holder, or on the gunnel, or passing it to another angler allows for the primary, or original angler to rest.

It is not a mere technicality, it is unfair advantage to the angler vis-a-vis landing the fish and to other anglers in a tournament.
 
Back
Top