What's better...

FinnBill

Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2005
RO Number
16856
Messages
147
What's better...a trawler or a sail boat for cruising the Carribean for say a year...living aboard for two people. Is there plentiful gas / diesel availability...and how much do you really sail? What is the typical range on a trawler?

thanks
 
Interesting question.

Haven't been in the Carribean but we had a sail boat many years ago before switching to trawlers. Range of a trawler is like asking how high is up. It all dependeds on the make and model. My old 34' CHB had a range of 1200 miles at about seven knots. With these high fuel prices I asked my wife if she would be interested in switching back to sail. Her responce was less then positive. I guess she would rather turn the page of her book then trim the gib. Lots more room on a trawler for the same LOA.

Dave
 
both are feasible... most trawlers have enough range to make it to the carib. with minimum stops in the bahamas. The longest stretch is from the Turks n Caicos to the Dominican Republic or puerto rico... about 200 to 300 miles. typical range ? i'd say 500 to 1000 miles... it really depends on the boat...

once in the islands, you're not more than 50 to 100 miles from a fuel dock...

if you're assuming 2nmpg, and a 4000 miles round trip down islands, you're looking $7k to $9k in fuel...

In the islands, you almost always have steady 10 to 15kts trade winds, from the east, so to answer your question... you can really rely on the wind and sail 99% of the times.
 
many non trawler motor yachts in the 40 ft range will also do 2 NMPG at 7 kts. There is nothing especially economical in the name trawler, mostly marketing baloney. For best stability in transiting the seas between islands I suspect a sail boat would be much better but once the hook is down the powerboat wins hands down.
 
Before buying, I would charter one of each type you are thinking about. I personally think I would have a hard time living aboard a sail boat for a year. Now there are some motorsailers that might be a little better. But for that length of a time I would go power, YMMV.
 
I've not done either, but my understanding is that motor sailer is the best of both worlds. Any one have experience with these?
 
Isn't that what they sailed in Captain Ron? ;)
 
"but my understanding is that motor sailer is the best of both worlds."

Or the worst.

Having been on many different types of both sail and trawlers, I'd go with a sail catamaran. Stable at anchor, shallow draft and lots of room inside and out.

And I also think you should charter before you by.
 
I have sailed for a considerable peroid of time in the Caribbean (both Eastern and Western). There are compromises of both a "trawler" and a sailboat. The sail boat has a deeper draft and may be limiting in the Bahamas (which are not part of the Caribbean). But in the true Caribbean 7 foot draft is rarely a problem (and that is what I carried on one of my trips there).

Buy the book by Bruce Van Sant "The Gentleman's Guide to Passages South, the Thornless path to Windward". Bruce has done this by both sailboat and trawler many times.

I personally feel that a monohull sailboat is the most practical vessel. My first preference is an older Cal 46. These have 85 hp diesel engines and at least 300 gallons of fuel, giving a range under power of over 1500 miles (I averaged 6 mpg at 6 knots-considerably less at 8 knots). They will power and sail at 8 knots. The 46 is of adequate size for supplies for a couple or even 4 for extended peroids and are well built and good sea boats, with a pilot house which makes life far more comfortable than the usual "cave" like interior of most sailboats.

I currently own a Cat--and there are multiple advantages, but considering the cost and some sea keeping issues, I still favor the monohull sailboat for that trip.
Consider that the vast majority of sailboats are designed for conditions which you will meet in route--and that most power boats are not. Stability and roll are a major factor with the power vessel.
As Pascal says, you will sail 99% of the time in the Caribbean--but there are several parts of the trip which can be to weather (into the wind and seas). We sailed mostly on reaches back and forth--but for example if you want to go from the British Virgins to Anquilla it will be directly into the wind and waves in an overnight trip. On the other hand, if you want to sail from the US Virgins to Granada, it will be a tight reach of several days duration.
 
well, from the VIs, you're better off going up to Anegada and then sail towards Saba or even statia. in winter, trade winds are a little north of due west so that should be feasible on one tack.... then from Saba you can head back toward St Barth, St Maarten and Anguila
 
"Buy the book by Bruce Van Sant "The Gentleman's Guide to Passages South, the Thornless path to Windward". Bruce has done this by both sailboat and trawler many times."

Bruce's current boat is for sale, he could just buy that. :-)
 
Back
Top