Who needs thrusters

jmicklov

Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2004
RO Number
15952
Messages
188
Talking about twin inboards here....
I recently read that you can actually make your boat move sideways. You put your stbd. in reverse and port in forward with left rudder and your boat will move sideways to port. It makes sense since 1 fwd. and 1 reverse would make the boat rotate and the left rudder would offset that.

Has anyone ever tried it?

I figure that you could do the same to stbd.

Have not tried it yet, but it would be a perfect way for me to dock my 330 Sea Ray Sundancer. My port is to the dock and I'm at the very end with another boat behind me.

Jack
 
it really depends on the boat (rudder size, prop size, bottom shape) but usually it's a maneuver that works only with no wind and no current. you're not going to be able to push against any kind of wind which is when you will need.

stick to basics and springs lines. if you dock alongside adn the wind pushes you off the dock, come at angle, grab your spring and go forward. boat will come alongside the dock.

I dont' have thrusters on my 53, and to be honest very rarely use them on the 70 I captain; usually i do because i dont' trust the cleats on some small/old docks and dont' want to rip them off springing a large boat.

Now, if your home dock is subject to bad currents/winds and you have some "dangers" like rocks, rough bulkhead, etc... looming really close, then it's worth considering. in 99% of the cases, not worth the $$$.
 
It doesn't really work on my boat. I tried. You do move sideways but it's almost impossible to do evenly and with no forward or backward motion. It doesn't work with both throttles at idle speed. It's not like you just turn the helm and click into gear and the boat magically walks sideways. Let us know how it works on your boat.
 
Since I'm in a river that is tidal, most of the time I'm dealing with currents, which in that case I'll come back a bit further along side the boat behind me and do the traditional approach at an angle where I can get close enough for someone to get onto the dock with the bow line. But usually in late summer the flow is minimal in either direction where this technique might work.

Jack
 
quote:

Originally posted by jmicklov

Since I'm in a river that is tidal, most of the time I'm dealing with currents, which in that case I'll come back a bit further along side the boat behind me and do the traditional approach at an angle where I can get close enough for someone to get onto the dock with the bow line. But usually in late summer the flow is minimal in either direction where this technique might work.

Jack






Sorry, but that is horribly dangerous, and well, wrong.

Arrange your lines so the eye of the spring line secures to your boat. If you are backing in, have someone grab the spring from the dock, secure it to the midship or aft cleat. If you are port side too, back down with your starboard engine (or both actually), and the boat will come right up alongside the dock. The added beauty about the eye being secured to the boat, is that the line is pre-set so you can not back into the dock - no guessing while tying a spring while docking. Also, no dnagers of anyone stepping off a boat unneccessarily.
 
i agree with ITK... getting close enough for someone to step off the boat is a recipe for accident.

leave your lines on the dock, if alongside, come in at angle and grab the spring with a boat hook. With the springs, i always use teh eye on the boat cleat, since springs are always put on with no tension. Having the eye on the boat cleat assures you that it's set correctly and that you wont' be able to back into theboat behind or the dock if in a slip.

i've seen people falling in the drink while stepping off boats that come in as you describe, not a pretty sight.
 
Back to the topic: I move my 47' houseboat sideways all the time (twin 350s, inboards with velvet drives). This is easiest done in a calm with low current, but I have done it on windy days, using a bit more throttle on one engine than another. It seems to me that this is one of those things that you can only learn by doing.
 
large rudders are a requirement for walking and smaller props help. I have seen it done several times by displacement boats. Semi planning boats usually have smaller rudders and don’t get the sideways push and instead twist.
My boat, for instance, with 33" props will turn in the direction indicated by the props at idle no matter what the rudders do. Shifting in and out of gear does shift the stern sideways a little but no more than shifting independent of the rudders.
 
I get the same results Bruce described. I have 22" props with relatively small rudders.
 
i don't have a bow thruster (wish i did.........lol) so yes i've learned to do with out it by either using the rudders as noted above or leaning the bow against a piling and using it to bring the stern along side. with a bit of practice I can pretty much make the boat move sideways in all but a strong breeze working against me.
 
Let me get this right in my head.
If the wind is pushing you away from the dock, and or you are in a tight docking situation with other boats. You should grab the rope on the dock with a boat hook and secure it to the midship cleat, or spring line cleat.Then bump the boat forward with both engines and the spring line will pull you to the dock. BRILLIANT!!! I UNDERSTAND!

I cant wait to try this the next time I'm fueling up.
I cant walk my twin screw in eather.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Tiki Time

Let me get this right in my head.
If the wind is pushing you away from the dock, and or you are in a tight docking situation with other boats. You should grab the rope on the dock with a boat hook and secure it to the midship cleat, or spring line cleat.Then bump the boat forward with both engines and the spring line will pull you to the dock. BRILLIANT!!! I UNDERSTAND!

I cant wait to try this the next time I'm fueling up.






If you are coming in stern too, you may want to use reverse instead of forward. ;)

Think of the spring line as your pendulum (sp?) and you pivot the boat against it to control where it goes.

Usually though I only use the outboard engine from the slip (in other words if I am coming in port side too, I will use the starboard engine to back down against the line), but no harm in using both.
 
Pascal and I have disagreed about thrusters many times; one of the points Pascal drives home is that once you have a thruster you may become reliant on them and therefore not develop the skills you need to handle your boat properly. I have always disagreed with that, till this weekend.
I lost my thruster last week while on vacation, conditions were windy and I was maneuvering in tight quarters, although I was able to handle my boat perfectly, I was sh-ting a brick not having the thruster available. I should not have felt this way because I feel I have learnt what my boat does in different conditions and when the week was done, I proved to myself I can live without the thruster. I will not short haul the boat to fix it; I will wait till the boat comes out in the winter.

A thruster is a great tool to learn how your boat maneuvers in wind, currents and tight quarters. If you get lazy and use it all the time, you will be in trouble one day when it fails, and it will fail!!!

This was my first fly-bridge boat, also the biggest boat I ever owned, the thruster took the fear out of damaging another persons boat while I was going through the learning process on how my boat handles around the dock. If you want the thruster for that, then I say go for it. If you want it to be a crucial tool to dock you boat, I would say that is not a good idea.

If you get one, try like hell not to use it and only use it if you have to. Also, using it “if you have to” does not mean that you want to get in on the first approach; there is nothing wrong with making multiple attempts to dock your boat that is part of the learning process.

Walter
 
As far as the line thing ITK and Pascal speak about, I hate to rely on other people to help me (crew and people on the dock). Also, using your lines assumes that there is someone at the dock that gets what you want to do.

I would prefer to be able to handle it myself (bow thruster)
 
I can't do this maneuver on my boat either. Rudders are too small.

I also rarely use my thrusters. I turn them on every time I am docking, but seldom employ them. Learning how to maneuver with your lines will make you look like a hero and keep your and other boats safe. The only irksome thing is that so many people do not know how to use their lines that deck hands assume you don't either. You have to be firm with them and let them know that you have it under control and just to do as you say.
 
quote:

Originally posted by millsan1

I also rarely use my thrusters. I turn them on every time I am docking, but seldom employ them.






This is exactly what I was going to say. As Walter points out, use the thruster as a tool not a crutch. You never know when one of the tools in your bag may be broken.

My boat will walk sideways but it's tough since I have prop pockets. Takes much more throttle control.
 
John,
I would imagine that with diesel it would be easier than your boat with gas? I too have prop pockets, plus small rudders. I have tried to walk the boat but was unsucessfull.
 
I am now curious about fwd / reverse and hard to port / stbd with outdrives...if I'm feeling froggy next weekend, I'll report back.
 
As to the original question, it varies by boat. I had one boat that would walk but only with a slight forward movement. Come to think of it, I've never tried it on my current boat. I've never needed to try yet, but now I'm curious as I have decent rudders. In any case, I single hand a LOT and MY reliance is on spring lines, either for or aft depending on the current.

Only thing I would add is where the eye goes on the line. For my own slip I don't leave lines, but its really easy to get into. When I'm out on my own, I tie a slightly longer spring line and leave the eye to hook to a cleat on the dock with a boat hook. Since I'm single handing, I don't get off the boat until I have at least two lines on. By handing people the eye to go onto the dock, I don't have to rely on them tying properly or using the right line length, I pull it in from the boat side. Single handing with a current it is often easier for me to get the stern cleat tied as I'm a little lower to the water there and can most quickly get a very short line from me to the dock, then quickly get back to the helm and bring the bow in from there. If I have a current I continue driving the boat until that second line is secured. If that's the bow, then usually I'm just a step or two from the helm to where I'm trying to get an eye on a dock cleat.

Anyway that's how I do it. Pretty much agree with Pascal on everything though.

One thing that drives me nuts is the guys who are not anywhere near the dock, running those blenders. Those guys don't have a clue and usually the ones you have to watch out for the most. Pretty funny to hear about a crash 'because the thruster quit". If you can't get to the dock without the blender, you have no business getting near anyone elses boat at all. I think its both incompetent and in some cases I would argue rather strongly for being negligent as well.

No matter what level you are at, it's fine, just so long as you are honest with yourself about your own abilities and don't go trying to do things in close quarters you either don't have the skill for or have never practiced. I always get defensive when somebody gets chided for knowing how to operate their boat as if they were somehow gifted with that ability. Like anthing else, if you see someone having an easy time, its because they spend dedicated time practicing. It's not easy but anyone can do it. It's the guys who buy blenders and go to the bar early that bug me, because they are the ones who take the easy way out and then want to blame everything but themselves when something goes wrong. Can't understand why I might be upset that they bumped my boat or nearly did. No clue and don't want one either. Pshaww.
 
Back
Top