Still on topic, but as a bit of a sidebar:
MikeeH said: "Hard paints are favored by those boaters in the warmer areas where the boats stay in the water year round."
I disagree. I would not use anything but an ablative ( in my case, warm, salt water ). It is the only thing that actually provides some "protection". The hard paints ( an epoxy base with biocides ) will work for awhile ( about6 mo ) them you need to refresh. After several cycles of this mess, you need to remove the "dead" epoxy paint. The hard paints -do- create less drag ( from the paint ). If you race your sailboat, use a hard, smooth anti-fouling paint. But in this case the performance benefit is worth it. Ablatives ( as in "self-removing"!!! ) work well against the fast growing aggressive barnacles and green goo. And though there is a slight increase in drag vs an unpainted bottom, a few weeks in the slip and you will have a bottom that resembles the moon, and mine will still look yucky red and work as well as the day the test started.
Many of the hard biocides were developed with the less demanding environment of a fresh water, cool season in mind. ( Partly because the early biocide types were not terribly aggressive. )
Note that in these days of ecological concern, the laws relating to bottom paints have been evolving rapidly. The old ablatives ( I forgot if it was lead or copper. Lead, I think. ) were taken off the market as a marine contaminant. I suspect that the biocide types will be included in the ever increasing scrutiny as well.
--
For cool area, freshwater boats that do NOT sit in the slip more than a week or two, you likely can avoid the entire issue, and "wear a bare bottom".
For cool area, freshwater boats that DO sit in the slip more than a week or two, youshould seriously consider bottom paint. Visit the individual manufacturers websites to wee what they offer that is designed for your conditions. ( Or call them. They LOVE to sell this stuff. ) You should also ask around several ( many ) boaters who boat the same way as you do, in the same area and get their comments. Sometimes, local wisdom reigns king.
For salt water use other than trailer boats, I would strongly advise using bottom paint appropriate for the boat type and usage. In most cases, this would be an ablative, but, again, contact other locals, in your area, as well as the manufacturer of the proposed paint.
Asto color:
MikeeH got it right: use one color for the first coat, then a different color on top. As far a "looking good", well, all things are relative. some of the hard paints do actually look good. IMHO, none of the ablatives look very attractive, though some are a bit better than others ( mostly due to the fact that they are "built to fall apart". By design they look like a three-day-old sunburn... )