Why the cost??

deltabighat

Member
exMember
Joined
Aug 17, 2004
RO Number
14904
Messages
493
A couple years ago I asked the same question to another boating forum and really got no answer at all. Here where I live in California you can buy a very nice 4000 sq ft home on 3/4 of an acre for 400,000.00. Yet if you want to pay the same for a new yacht, you get 800-1000 sq ft of liveable space, often times with less than roomy accomadations. Some that size cost a million. I know there are a lot of variables but the two do not equate. One guy said boats were hand made one by one....duh so are houses. Houses have much more plumbing, electrical, computers, air conditioning, roofing, cement, carpet, tile etc and you also own the land. Why are many of the new boats so expensive. The last anwser I recieved may bave been close. One guy said he has know a lot of boat builders and none of them make any money and most close their doors.

DBH
 
Slick marketing of the lifestyle very similar to an engagement ring?
 
What kind of water view does your $400,000 house in California have? Can you move it anywhere you like? What happens when PG&E goes down or the water main breaks? What type of sewer system do you have? How about the navigation system? All the things that make the boat float, self sufficient completely off the grid, and able to go places are the big difference. The small production quantities of the components compared to mass produced house stuff is another factor. Building a house out of wood sticks is much cheaper and requires much less skill and labor than molding one out of FRP and making everything fit.

George
currently sitting on several thousand acres of pristine water with nobody spoiling the view or making noise next door, at anchor in the Florida Keys. Care to put a price on that?
 
When the tide comes up the boat floats, the beach house don't. If you don't like your neighbors you can just get underway until you find folks you like.
 
Houses are just poorly made boats. Stick 'em in the lake and they sink! ;-)
 
See how much the price of the house goes up when you slap a couple of diesels that can push the house at 20+ MPH.
 
Why does a Maserati cost more than a Hyundai?
 
Where I live a good starter home can be had for around 100k (since the recent housing slump), same price as some higher end luxury sports cars. Kind of hard to live in a sports car, doesn't have a kitchen, bedroom, or bathroom. And the cars are produced in mass quantities on an assembly line. The starter house and sports car don't equate either, so why should a boat and a house?
 
Over here on the esat coast: houses don't have 2 expensive diesel engines, their own electric generating power plant, complete sewer plant, etc. A house can be built in less than 6 weeks with a crew of 4 people. A million dollar yacht is also going to have higher quality finishes both inside and out. I have not seem any big yacht with vinly siding and $3 sq yard carpet.
 
This could come under the same question as to why is a Ferrari worth more than a house?

Non mass-produced "luxury items" , boats, cars, planes/helicopters etc, have years of R&D costs involved in the design/manufacture. The market is small therefore production and manufacture costs can be exhorbitant.

Houses are built in their billions, raw materials/bricks/mortar etc. Piping/wiring/electrical roofing is mass produced with next to no cost. No years of R&D involved, man has been building houses for thousands of years.
Every man and his dog has one or wants one.

Economics? Supply & Demand? Perceived luxury comes with additional cost?
 
You answered most of that question yourself, when you said you own the land. I bet that same home in my neck of the woods, upstate rural New York, would cost about 200K, which widens the gap even more.
My complaint about the cost of boats is why do they have to be as luxurious as they are. My home does not have Corian countertops, nor does it have solid cherry cabinets. It also doesn't have Ultra Leather upholstery, or custom made mattresses, bedspreads and sheets.
I think boatbuilders would be doing everyone a favor if they remember that most of the population doesn't live as well at home, so there is no need to use all these expensive appointments when most people use the boat a few days a week, and a few months of the year.
Have you ever noticed that those people that live aboard their boat 24/7/365 have the least expensive appointments??
Production boat builders are trying to make their boats equal to yachts, and not a lot of us can afford a yacht, or need one.
That Hyundai will get you back and forth to work, the same way as the Maserati does.....just not in the lap of luxury.

Boat buying today is a lot like buying a car.....options are no longer options, they are either included or in order to have one option you need to buy a "package" with 4 options even though you don't want the other 3.
Start with the hull and engines, and let the customer choose all the amenities....I bet that would cut the cost down quite a bit.
 
Boat $400K
Fuel $2K to fill tank
Beer $50
Day on water: Priceless
 
I agree with Dave live in a house not near the water where you may or may not be able to insure it. Get a boat and not a new one. Boats depreciate faster than even homes at this point in time. If you have a boat and don't like your neighbors move it, don't like the weather changes move it, try that with a house. Also as George said a live a board boat is entirely self sufficient with the exception of fuel. Boat systems are generally more complex than your average house. Even then if you get a motor-sailor you won't need as much fuel. In today's market at $400k used you are likely to be able to purchase a boat that can at a minimum take you around this hemisphere. I am glad my wife and I decided to purchase a boat instead of a 2nd house at the shore. Who would have thought that would be a better deal?
Bill
 
Boat builders can charge what they do because they have a captive audience that is willing to pay that price, just that simple. Take away that audience, and the cards fall (todays times).
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

Boat builders can charge what they do because they have a captive audience that is willing to pay that price, just that simple. Take away that audience, and the cards fall (todays times).




Walter I believe the house building market is in just as bad shape as boat builders perhaps worse off?
Bill
 
have you compared the price of a gallon of concrete vs a gallon of resin????
... or a few cement blocks vs fiberglass matt?
... or construction grade plywood to make concrete columns vs the mold needed to build a boat?
... or steel bars vs Dyvinicel?
 
Great stuff everyone...I really had not thought of something someone above mentioned. Up until the last 6-8 months, houses appreciated year after year and were one the the great investments any homeowner, regardless of the size of their home, could participate in. All boats, regardless of size depreciate year after year. One other point is the cost to slip your boat. Slip fees on a 40 footer ain't cheap. I guess I am like a lot of folks here....I love my boat and have always owned one or two at a time even at times when divorce was threatened when discussing getting another boat. I use mine all the time and could never imagine not having one. Some folks think they are boaters but seem to be the happiest when they sell theirs. Even with all the good points, I still don't quite understand why larger boats are so darn expensive.

DBH
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

have you compared the price of a gallon of concrete vs a gallon of resin????
... or a few cement blocks vs fiberglass matt?
... or construction grade plywood to make concrete columns vs the mold needed to build a boat?
... or steel bars vs Dyvinicel?






Have you compared square footage, plus land?
 
Back
Top