Wifi Booster

biglar

Member
exMember
Joined
Dec 10, 2004
RO Number
15878
Messages
128
Some time ago on this forum, there was quite a bit of discussion regarding wifi signal boosters at the receiver end. I've looked as far back as I can, and don't see those threads.

My situation has changed, and frequently I only get a 1 or 2 bar signal, and need to amplify it to connect. Looking on the 'net shows some products, but I'm not sure which would be the best, or which to avoid.

Can you guys offer some suggestions ?? Thanks.

Lar.
 
We have used Digitals' 500 series, and it works fine. The one major problem is that the antenna in the boat and the one out, have to be 20 ft. apart, and on some boats that is hard, pwr. especially. I also use the same system at home, due to poor signal, and it works fine, however it does help when you are in the general area of the internal ant.
 
I use this one, it works very good. About $55. It connects to the laptop via usb port. In the house on my 1 year old HP laptop it picks up 3 other networks vs. just the home network.

CU5_antenna_90degree.jpg


Niles
 
5milewifi.com got some good press in the December issue of ...was it Cruising World??? The bottom line of that article was that one needs an external antenna for decent wifi reception on a boat. Fiberglass and moisture aren't real friendly to 2.4Ghz signals. I've got a 9dB external omni antenna and a 1watt amp. I can pull in stuff from miles away. Here's the wifi thread I think you were trying to find:

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic...ork+...+-inforum:yahoo.com+-inforum:yedda.com
 
Thanks for the information, but now you've all got me a little puzzled. That little Alfa for $55.00 looks good, so why pay $400 to $2,000 to do the same job ??.....or does it do the same job ?? I'm not real hot on this stuff, so please keep it fairly simple. Thanks again......

Lar.
 
As with many things, you get what you pay for. That Alfa is probably 5-10 times better than the built in wifi antenna on your laptop. The system I use (with a 1watt amp and external antenna) is more like 20-30 times better (very roughly speaking). The specs I find on the Alfa are 500mw amp with and a 2dB antenna. So it's got half the power and much less gain. But the real trick on a boat is getting the antenna outside. It appears the Alfa's antenna is removable. Thus, you could hook it to an external antenna. That would be worth a try for the price. Just keep the cable between the Alfa and the antenna as short as possible (there's a TON of loss in the cable).

Again, 5milewifi looks like it will work and is together in a nice package. However, for $400 it is a little steep. Here's a hi-gain alternative:

1-watt amp (same one I have) - $170 (http://www.l-com.com/productfamily.aspx?id=6050)
8.5dBi antenna - $50 - (http://www.l-com.com/productfamily.aspx?id=6269)
20' of antenna cable - $30 (http://www.l-com.com/item.aspx?id=21153)

Then find a wireless adapter for your laptop that has a removable antenna (usb or otherwise) for around $50 and you've got a kickin' setup for around $300.
 
Biglar, Not real sure of your needs but my stock laptop antenna only gave me one or two bars while sitting at the dinette in our boat; while at our dock. The little alpha (I did buy a better antenna for it $6) brought it up to full signal strength. While visiting other marinas clubs I have always been able to connect. I have no need to connect while away from the dock. I did try while anchored a couple miles out in front of Cleveland for the air show last fall, I found networks but they were all secure.
Good luck
Niles
 
quote:

Originally posted by nwaring

Biglar, Not real sure of your needs but my stock laptop antenna only gave me one or two bars while sitting at the dinette in our boat; while at our dock. The little alpha (I did buy a better antenna for it $6) brought it up to full signal strength. While visiting other marinas clubs I have always been able to connect. I have no need to connect while away from the dock. I did try while anchored a couple miles out in from of Cleveland for the air show last fall, I found networks but they were all secure.
Good luck
Niles




That's the path I will probably take. Start with the minimum needed, and then step it up from there. Why go full bore if not needed?

In my case, our dock was relocated to the other side of the marina a few weeks ago (owing to low lake levels), and I lost WiFi signal. It's just not shooting far enough out. I'll get zero to one bar. If I could just boost that to 2-3 bars, I know I will be fine. You don't need full and perfect signal strength for general internet use.

Paul
 
I purchased the latest (5) 2 mile WiFi (all mounted in the antenna), I was less than impressed. If you want inexpensive and better than just the card in your computer then it's better. If you want the best, it costs. By far the best unit and I have tested them all is the Syrens HP-AP. There has been a split so the real unit not Syrens Lite is available through Geo-Sat Solutions out of Hollywood Florida. I have the unit that also has a low power AP as well as the high power all in one. This allows you to rebroadcast the longer range link in and around the boat you just have to make sure you set the low power AP 3 channels away from the High Power with the external antenna. The 5 mile WiFi needs 2 USB ports if you don't have 2 USB ports open then you need an optional 12VDC USB adapter. The software is easy to use and actually works with Window wireless. The software for the GeoSatSolutions is easy to use as will but must be loaded via CD.

Regards Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by biglar

Thanks for the information, but now you've all got me a little puzzled. That little Alfa for $55.00 looks good, so why pay $400 to $2,000 to do the same job ??.....or does it do the same job ?? I'm not real hot on this stuff, so please keep it fairly simple. Thanks again......

Lar.





Lar, to be honest you are comparing apples to oranges. I can routinely get 6 to 8 miles away from shore and pick up 5 to 10 open networks. I can get 8 miles from my marina and still connect at speeds close enough to surf the net. The most important thing as Kurt mentioned is get an external antenna but unless your amplifier is located within 10' do not try using small diameter coaxial cable you will need LMR400 even that between an external antenna and amplifier and you can loose large amounts of signal (7-8db) and introduce the noise from the cable loss into your receiver. If you decide to use the $55.00 box run a USB cable near the external antenna and then mount the tiny amp within 3-4 feet of the antenna for optimum performance.
Bill
 
Thank you all very much. I can mount the antenna about 6 feet from point of use, so is it OK to cut the co-ax, or is it tuned like VHF cable ?? I'll go ahead and try the $55.00 cheapie....where-ever I've had problems, it's usually been a case of weak signal or no signal. Weak I can amplify. Thanks again.

Lar.
 
Lar unless you have the proper connector to put on the end of the cable and the proper crimp tool don't cut it. It is not tuned. I am not that familiar with that adapter is the connection reverse SMA or a normal SMA connector? Here is a link to the USB WiFi adapter shown above.
http://www.data-alliance.net/servlet/the-90/802.11g-USB-802.11b-802.11n/Detail
I just checked it has an RP-SMA. Call around to a two way radio shop or Computer networking company and tell them you have a WiFi antenna and need a RP-SMA connector crimped on. You will also need to tell them the cable type, it should be in writing on the antenna cable's jacket every foot or so. By the way most Marine grade WiFi antennas are either type N connectors or TNC but even the type TNC can be reverse TNC. The N connector is the only connector that does not come in a reverse pole connector. Do not try any splice connectors on this type of set-up or you will be better off leaving the cable as it is.
Bill
 
I knew Bill would find this thread and put some perspective on things (hey, he REALLY knows what he's talking about considering this sort of thing is what he does for a living).

Lar, I think you'll do fine starting on the more affordable end and moving up if you have to. Bill and I are on the East Coast and have to deal with getting signal offshore and such (for me, it's an annual trip to the Abacos/Bahamas, and some serious range is quite important there). But if you're inland, just do anything that gets an antenna on the outside and you'll probably be happy. Heck, when I'm home in the Chesapeake, I'm usually connected to Verizon via my external CDMA antenna and amp, to heck with wifi at that point.
 
If you want the best you can get at a reasonable price, and simple to use with out having to mount stuff and run cables, look up hawking technologies, just do a search for it. They have a unit that is usb conected, portable, and directional. It will bring in a signal from 6 miles away, great little unit, and extreamly easy to use...........D........
 
I looked at Hawking's site and saw only units for the transmitting end. Which product do you mean ??

I won't cut the cable. I believe what you say, Bill.

Verizon is the reason I'm going thru all this. I have the aircard, and aside from being slow, (230 kps) they've apparently got someone else piggy-backed onto my account. Last summer while on vacation they admitted it, and adjusted the bill. Since then, I fight with them every month over my bill. They always adjust it, but never down to where it should be.....and I am totally sick and tired of their b.s. I want alternatives. I did find a used satellite receiver dish for $3,000.00, but don't want to spend that much, and don't really have room for a 4 foot footprint. I think Verizon is too greedy, and I'm tired of them.

Lar.
 
One thing I will mention that so far I haven't seen. If you are serious about your electronics they need to be NEMA rated. I have my HP-AP under my hardtop. It is NEMA4 rated and has a desiccant protection. Boats if left in the water, heck even out of the water are very hard on electronics due to moisture from heating and cooling in enclosed areas and direct sunlight's heating and cooling in a moisture laden environment. The professional units have both forms of protection if their circuit boards are not conformal coated. Its just another thing to think about when considering a consumer device vs. a marine grade device.
Now as far as Kurt's other good point I like him also use a Cellular based 3G system(s) as well. I use the Ericsson W-25 which works on AT&Ts network using the UMTS/WCDMA platform. The unit also supplies a digital phone line and you can use the phone and internet at the same time. The unit also has a 4 port Ethernet switch. The speeds when I am in UMTS/WCDMA approach 3.5G speeds. Since my business is tied to communications with my customers and employees by using the internet I choose to have 3 systems to access internet. They are starting the worst to best, KVH TracPhone 252 9600baud (last resort) however it is the only way for me to receive faxes on the boat, then my GeoSatSolutions high power WiFi solution and last the Ericsson W-25 on AT&T, I can also choose a Sprint only Lynksys router that is combined into the W-25s external amplifier and external Digital cellular antenna mounted high on my arch.
Again this is above what the average boater needs but since I do this stuff for a living (in large buildings not marine applications) I feel the need to be properly equipped. It allows me to spend 4 days out of 7 at the boat instead of in the office.
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by biglar

I looked at Hawking's site and saw only units for the transmitting end. Which product do you mean ??

I won't cut the cable. I believe what you say, Bill.

Verizon is the reason I'm going thru all this. I have the aircard, and aside from being slow, (230 kps) they've apparently got someone else piggy-backed onto my account. Last summer while on vacation they admitted it, and adjusted the bill. Since then, I fight with them every month over my bill. They always adjust it, but never down to where it should be.....and I am totally sick and tired of their b.s. I want alternatives. I did find a used satellite receiver dish for $3,000.00, but don't want to spend that much, and don't really have room for a 4 foot footprint. I think Verizon is too greedy, and I'm tired of them.

Lar.




I don't have a sophisticated answer for you, but I can just add a few thoughts I have had.

I am on an inland lake, and I'm really only worried about WiFi at the slip. I can check email out on the lake via my cell phone (Sprint), and the internet as well (though it's a hassle on the small screen).

So what I've thought is a few things--

1. I am just about 300' from being within range of the WiFi at our marina since they have moved our dock (have two houseboats blocking the signal). I am going to try the cheap route to see if it is enough to simply boost me within range again.

2. I am also considering an air card through Sprint. I can get the card for free and unlimited air time for $60-70/mo (can't recall exact rate). My wife had the Sprint card for work and we used it all the time. I was quite impressed with the speed. With that, I could skip the booster and just use the card whether slipped, or on the hook.

3. The last option I am considering what I mentioned earlier; just boosting the signal for use at the marina, and then using my existing unlimited Sprint plan ($99/mo) for phone, texts, and internet access via cellular.

I'm not a Sprint employee, and I know there are plenty of haters out there, but they are proven to be the fastest 3G network overall. Sure, I've had issues with them over the 8+ years I've been with them, but they keep trying hard to keep me every time I threaten to cancel. I just happen to really like the all-inclusive unlimited data plan that is the same amount every month.

Good luck.
 
I apperently mis-understood your issue. I thought you were picking up a wifi signal, you are actually using a cell service with an air card, the hawking tech product wont help you, it is strictly for picking up wifi signals from long distances. I would suggest looking into other service providers such as att or sprint or force verizon to fix yours.........D.........
 
Back
Top