Bilge Pump Float Switch

divedaddy

Member
exMember
Joined
Nov 16, 2006
RO Number
24262
Messages
836
Oldfishboat's story about the high water alarm reminded me, here's a question - do you regularly check your bilge pump float switches?

I ask because I am now installing my third switch since January. The first replacement was for a switch that no longer worked. I replaced the old caged switch with a new Rule Super Switch. Three months later the "new" switch would no longer pivot - wherever you placed it it stayed, and no amount of water would raise it. If it did turn on it wouldn't turn off after the water was pumped out. Two months later and the second "new" switch, also a Rule Super Switch, is doing the same thing. This hasn't been a problem because my boat doesnt leak any detectable amount - the only water that tends to accumulate is from rains that blow in around the edges.

I only manged to catch these because I manually check the switches before every departure or as part of my weekly check if we don't go anywhere. Oh, and the next switch won't be a Rule Super Switch.
 
i check them all usually once a month or whenever i'm close to them...

i use the standard rule stitch, usually last a few years.

it's a good idea to have a second larger pump with it's own float switch set higher than the normal water level. this way the switch stays clean and dry... cheap insurance.
 
The only reason for a "New" switch to fail would be for it to become gummed up with oil leakage...debris...generally dirty bilge water. Other than that it"s only a pivot and the pivot is what"s not working apparently. SOoooooooooooooooooo.....either you"ve got more water coming in than you think.................you"ve got a dirty bilge that"s crudding up the pivot.......OR...your float switch isn"t sitting level and the angle (however slight) is affecting the pivoting action of the float itself.
 
I have 7 regular bilge pumps (2 are for the shower stalls) plus 2 "high level" pumps that are hooked to alarms. If either of these two kick in, they set off a LOUD alarm that will let someone know there is a problem.
Replaced all my pumps and float switches when I bought the boat in 2000 ( I added the high water units) and have not had a problem with any of them yet, knock on wood!
 
Gummed up sticking floats usually don't need replacement. Just spray the hinges with WD-40 while working the float up & down then finish with a good teflon spray. It should last a lot longer and the teflon spray will make even new ones resist gumming far longer. I work the sprays in about once a season or whenever I'm down in there.

Just make sure the hold down screws are not too tight, angled and binding the hinges.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Tanqueray

The only reason for a "New" switch to fail would be for it to become gummed up with oil leakage...debris...generally dirty bilge water. Other than that it"s only a pivot and the pivot is what"s not working apparently. SOoooooooooooooooooo.....either you"ve got more water coming in than you think.................you"ve got a dirty bilge that"s crudding up the pivot.......OR...your float switch isn"t sitting level and the angle (however slight) is affecting the pivoting action of the float itself.






Your point is valid. My point was about checking them - if I hadn't I would not have known.

For sure it was dirt and crud - I've done a lot of work in the engine compartment since first of the year. What I find surprising is how easily these switches become compromised. I tried cleaning the fouled switches, but without any success. My high water pump and switch (an older caged switch) sit just above the main - not a foot apart, and this one is as good as new.
 
It just seems odd that you"d have gone through three switches since January already. There has to some issue there other than a bad switch. I could see maybe ONE being Faulty(?) and maybe a flaw in the manufacturing or something..but not three of them. There"s something else going on there. What about the mounting? Is it mounted on a level surface? Or if it isn"t is it at least mounted in such a way as to provide a free swing of the arm up and down with no possibility of it binding up?
 
Divedaddy

floathomegroundtakle001.jpg


What can I say. This thing is well used !!! Something close to 20 boats non mine kept off the bottom with it. So I dont think most do check from what I see.

Pleasure crusers most of em simply do not put enough thought into keeping the basement dry. Such as checking float switchs and stuffing boxs < grin >. Some times we just get lazy LOL.

Back ups, alarms, aux pumps, etc its all good IMO.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Tanqueray

It just seems odd that you"d have gone through three switches since January already. There has to some issue there other than a bad switch. I could see maybe ONE being Faulty(?) and maybe a flaw in the manufacturing or something..but not three of them. There"s something else going on there. What about the mounting? Is it mounted on a level surface? Or if it isn"t is it at least mounted in such a way as to provide a free swing of the arm up and down with no possibility of it binding up?






The first switch appeared to be the OEM switch, and that one just quit making contact, but it still pivoted well. The two replacements were the surprising failures - both developed the same sticky switch problems, and both were the same switch model.

My mechanic is as baffled as I am. The mounting is free - nothing to bind on - the float doesn't touch anything extraneous. He chose the Super Switch as he figured it would be the better switch - at least Rule (Jabsco) markets it that way. It seems they are very susceptible to fouling somewhere in the pivot mechanism. Today he put in a simple Rule-A-Matic, the same switch that is in the shower sump that appears to be the ten-year old original.

This all serves as a reminder of importance of a fairly inexpensive part ($25 - $25). I learned long ago about the importance of keeping the pumps working properly, so I will keep checking (both pumps and switches) every week plus every departure.
 
I use to have the same propblem with faulty switches. Many years ago I replaced my bilge pumps with the auto type. No switch required however you can install one as a back up if you wish. No more switches to go bad and very simple to check for operation.

I only use the float switch pump now for the shower sump only.

Dave

Faster now but still steady
 
which way is the float facing ? make sure it is installed facing the closest bulkhead so that bilge
water rushing up or down the bilge when getting on and off plane cannot damage the float.

if installed sideways, same thing. when you get on and off plane, the water flow could be putting too much
pressure on the float and damage the hinge.

check out the install instructions, it's all explained.
 
Are you in fresh water or salt water?

Any changes in the wiring since the first of the year?

Do you have an oily bilge?

Yes, I do check out the floats & pumps. Also check running lites, hoses, belts, zincs & strainers to name a few. When I find water in the bilge, I do the taste test to determine fresh water or salt water to help in accessing where it came from.

Good Luck
 
El Sea - brackish.

Ronald - I assure you, it's not gas. It's grunge from repair work. We had to grind off manifold bolts in January and that generated a lot of metal dust / rust that fouled the pivots. They wouldn't clean out readily and switches are cheap so I replaced them.

Two points I wanted to make with this thread - check your switches as they can fail in more than one way (electrical contact, fouling of the pivot, etc.), and they can foul much easier than I thought possible.
 
fresh or salt woudln't affect the ability of the float to move... gas either... unless
maybe he had a lot of gas inthere... in which case he'd have more worrysome issues starting
with a malfunctioning PSS (personal smell sensor) :-)

oil either... Detroits are reknowed leakers and the oil doens't affect my float switches...

i'm still betting on mechanical damage from water surging... Eric, which way are they facing, are
they exposed to water movements ?

bad idea to taste the water, even a drop... lots or chemicals in there... to check for salt, put
little water on a dark material in the sun... if salt, it will leave salty residue
 
Just a thought. Maybe packing the pivot area with silicone grease. Doesn't wash away very easily and little affected by petroleum solvents. Won't melt or freeze. Keeps grit out.

Might have to check for free movement, though.[:I]
 
the reason I asked about salt water, I have seen pumps fail because of electrolis...
 
It wasn't pump failure.

The original switch failed due to corrosion of the electrical connection. The replacement switches failed by sticking - wouldn't pivot properly, but if manually activated worked fine.
 
I have seen pumps go bad over time from crevice corrosion of the shaft to the impeller.
Get some muck ( like hair ) stuck in there and add a bit of water in the bilge.
After some time in water the shaft rots out. Pump runs but will not pump water.

Just another good reason to check pumps / float switchs.
 
Back
Top