Boating Ethics Question

Ethics- I wouldn't haul the boat just to fill up. You are using the marina's ramp. If everyone did it, they would have to charge slip owners a ramp fee. Or stop selling gas if they don't sell enough. BUT, I would certainly fill up if the boat is out of the water and coming back to the marina. That is expected. Also, consider if the marina's gas price is in line with other marinas. That weighs.
 
In our area any ramp on a Corps or TVA lake has to provide their ramp free to the public by law. If I built a ramp in my back yard down to Old Hickory I would have to let the public use it any time they wanted to - no charge. so using the marina's ramp involves no obligation on your part as generally speaking it is a public ramp. Things may be different in Michigan and your mileage may vary.
 
Not so here on the Ohio River. Lots of marinas have launch ramps and they all charge a fee to launch a boat. So in Tenn, if you let someone lauch from a ramp on your property and they get hurt, is the state liable or are you?
 
The State or the Feds as it has become public property once you build the ramp. Please understand that you have to apply for a permit to do this.

Going back to the original question, if you pay to put in or take out then it is certainly in your best interest to find the least expensive fuel considering the costs of all the manipulations involved - but the marina owner certainly has to keep these thoughts in his consideration as to who is his distributor and what amount he is charged.

If I had a trailerable boat and there was a $0.50 per gallon differential or more, I would certainly consider pulling and putting back in after a fill up.
 
I would do it too, but that Speedway is in the WORST location ever for a trailer. LOL!!!
 
Nothing wrong with saving money.
My argument would be "I need to conserve money somewhere to afford the prices I pay the marina for servicing my boat". I haul the PWC's every time to fill in the eves, and only use the marina as "a matter of convenience" if we burn through a tank short of a day due to use. Given we are now only 60% full on docks, I don't see my marina doing me any favors by dropping their prices on anything (rule of supply and demand to keep business). I may start shopping marina's just to save more money!
 
quote:

Originally posted by nitwit

I would do it too, but that Speedway is in the WORST location ever for a trailer. LOL!!!






Stalker! :D

Yes, the Speedway in question is a #($%)%*& to get in to. A few weeks ago I chanced it, pulled out of the marina and the Speedway was dead empty!! It was like God wanted me to top off that day...lol.
 
your savings by using speedway etc can actually be more than you think. If you get gas at a gas staion and use that gas for anything other than on the road you are entitled to the road tax back.. that goes for federal and state. I have been doing it for over 10 years. this includes your lawnmower, ATV, dirt bike, airplane, generator, boat. basickly anything off road. You have to keep all reciepts and an acountant helps the first time around. But it can amount to a significant amount of money at the end of the year. Also personally I feel gas at a gas station is actually better than Marina gas and this is not based on anything other than freshness. Depending on your marina some (slow ones) may only get gas once or twice a season. your local BP gets a load almost daily. fresh gas is better gas...
 
From what you've said, you still buy gas at the marina every other time. You are supporting them. I never buy gas from my marina because they charge $1.25+ over street price per gal. I go to another Marina and save .50-.75 a gal. They get plenty of my money other ways, I dont feel obligated to hand them an extra $50 everytime I gas up.
 
I guess a lot depends on the price differance... Plus grade 89 octane at our marina has been $4.50 a gal. since the begining of the season, meanwhile the price for gas "on the street creeps up almost daily. Currently street price for 89 octane is about $4.09 a gal. thats .41 cents. for being able to gas up, w/o the hassle of loading the boat on the trailer and hauling to a gas station. Saves wear n' tear on our truck and fuel for that too! We minimize the pain at the pump by buying gas when the gauge drops to half full! Our marina does'nt make "a profit" on the gas, only to cover the cost of environmental (spill, fire) insurance. not a bad deal!
 
I Guess I am in the middle. I would not go through the hassle of hauling out to get gas since its quite a chore for my boat but I do get street gas full ups when I am out of the water for something else. My marina is expensive but convenient. I want to keep the marina in business. I have not seen any marinas close but I have seen other lake related stores and eateries close for lack of business, so I want to give them some of my gas business.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jlee815

I Guess I am in the middle. I would not go through the hassle of hauling out to get gas since its quite a chore for my boat but I do get street gas full ups when I am out of the water for something else. My marina is expensive but convenient. I want to keep the marina in business. I have not seen any marinas close but I have seen other lake related stores and eateries close for lack of business, so I want to give them some of my gas business.






So the $1500 I pay them every year, plus the price of the seasonal pumpout pass doesnt support them enough? We've all come to the conclusion that marinas dont profit largely from the actual gas sale, its what you purchase at the store.

Its not like I'd be saving $.20 per gal. We are talking ~$.90/gallon, my trailer is sitting at the marina where I pay to store it (more support to the marina) and the Speedway is 200 feet from my trailer. Its not like Im driving 20 miles to save $.20 here...
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

Does your marina charge to use THEIR ramp for haulout??






No, and right next door is a public ramp. Whats your point? Whats the difference if I haul out for service or bring it home to wash it in my driveway vs. getting gas? So if I top off gas on the way back to the marina from a service call, Im in the wrong??
 
Just throwing this out there - since "ethics" is in the title of the thread - I don't see how gouging boaters with $1.00/gallon or MORE over street prices is ETHICAL at all, but that's just me. The local operator gave me the excuse of "well, that's what the delivery truck charges me since I only get _____ gallons per delivery." I called BS on that and did a little digging, chatted with some of the local fuel folks, yep, it was BS. They are just marking it way up - hey, their choice, and I choose not to buy it from them. I don't fill up at the marina, there's a few of us that go to a courtesy dock all by our lonesome and fill up. Much safer than the real fuel dock, you know, with all the people, slips, etc. around it - there's actually a dining area just 10 feet from one of the pumps...and folks smoke out there...
 
quote:

Originally posted by Captain Buddha

Just throwing this out there - since "ethics" is in the title of the thread - I don't see how gouging boaters with $1.00/gallon or MORE over street prices is ETHICAL at all, but that's just me.





Amen Brotha :D
 
Nope, but you probably haul it out and wash it at the marina with his water too! If you "know" the answer then why ask the question in the first place.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

Nope, but you probably haul it out and wash it at the marina with his water too! If you "know" the answer then why ask the question in the first place.






Hey, dont hate - appreciate. :D I live about 3 miles from the marina and I have never hauled out and washed my boat at the marina (power washer too cumbersome to transport,imo) but I do wash it in my well, like every other person there.
I came here for opinions, and I received them. To me, in this thread of boaters alike, more than 3/4 say "go for it" and there is no unethical approach to gassing up across the way, albeit at my expense of towing, which a few hundred feet isnt going to come close to closing the "savings gap" vs. gassing up at the marina.
 
Back
Top