Pascal. Being a Livingston owner I dont agree with your take.
This is a pic thats something over ten years past now. Towing my 10 foot behind the old 32 foot woodie. I also had the weaver davits to hang the Livingston on. However I prefer to tow 90 percent of the time. I used the weaver system for storage.
This be a typical spot I would anchor into too. The "beaches" on this coast are not so kind on the expensive type tenders. Tube boats and I dont seem to get along very well.
One thing I love about these boats is the interior room. Ya being hard means they dont have a ton of reserve bouyancy but you wont see peoples butts hangin over the sides. The load goes inside with lots of freeboard.
This run would have bin about 15 miles turn around to pick up some family that were joining us for a few nights. Three adults two dogs with luggage. Its nice to have that ability being able to transport a good sized load. Again no butts sitting on the gunnels its all inside. Lots of freeboard, gets up and planes, nice and safe IMO.
Not unusual for me to do a 10 to 20 mile run in 1 or 2 foot chop with ease. I have yet to sink one. I understand its possable but its just not bin my experience. Ya I have swamped it after it did the kite deal. But I just ran till most of the water bailed out on its own and finished the job with the bailing bucket. I coulda just pulled the plugs but bailing was faster.
I have also swamped it while towing. But no big deal it only takes on so much water then off loads it over the stern. When we hit calm water again I just bailed it out.
Both them times the cause was self inflicted.
They tow great. They have good freeboard. They are tough little boats. They are stable. Its a cat hull so they are even fast and run smooth. They dont realy bang or bounce like the whaler ride.
Just my take from like 15 years of owning them.
This is a 12T that I have placed too much power on. My choice.
I realy enjoyed the 10 with a 15 two stroke. Great for three to dive off. I even used it to transport off road motor bikes in. Not something you would do with a tube boat or whaler of this size.
I like my little Livingston. Can ya tell. < grin >