Dinghy question

ccdjoe

Member
Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2005
RO Number
19482
Messages
157
My inflatable Zodiac/Bombard dinghy disappeared from my dock (possibly stolen or blown away in high wind recently. . . now being searched for) and will probably need to be replaced. I have never really liked the inflatable and have towed it rather than mounted somehow on my 32' flybridge Beneteau. I recently saw a rig with a small dory with motor being towed which really appeals to me. I think I would use something like that to run around in my sheltered creek for pleasure and possibly fishing in the shoals. Opinions please.
 
I am a fan of the hard sided dinghy. They are generally cheaper, tougher & last far longer than an inflatable. The downside is that they are not as stable as an inflatable.

The best compromise I've tried is the Livingston catarmaran dinghy. It rows good, tows good, runs well with a small motor, is stable & is tough.
 
You can tow anything you'd like, Whalers, jetskis, ect. I prefer towing an inflatable though as when I'm nearing bridges or mooring fields I can shorten up the bridle enough so if I hit reverse theres rubber pontoons banging off my stern versus aluminum or fiberglass. Have you considered a RIB? I don't hear many complaints about that style-towing or performance wise.
Good luck,
Mike
 
I have an Avon 360DL (RIB) with a 40HP Yamaha 4 stroke & I love it. It does everything well & does about 40mph. I have a davit & haul it up to my stern bridge deck for storage.
 
Here's a Livingston 7', I think. Planes with 1 adult with a 3hp. Scoots along real nice with 2 adults.

109_0999.jpg
 
I would not recommend a true dory for a dinghy. The dory is nearly double ended (Tombstone tramsom--which is very narrow at the water line. The waterline beam is very low, with lots of flair; this makes the boat very unstable when not loaded, but as you pickup weight (fish) then the boat settles down in the water, and becomes stable. I own a semi dory--which has a broad transom and is very stable, with a fairly broad beam water line, and flat bottom, slight "V" foreward in my perticular boat (C Dory 25).

A dinghy with a flat bottom, square stern, good beam water line, and high bow, would be a reasonable skiff type of dinghy. Not row as well as a true dory--but take an outboard much better. True dories have to have an outboard in a well--there is not room on the transom.
 
Joe, is your 32 big enough for Davits at the stern?
Maybe you could hang a 12' Aluminum with a motor across the stern on Davits?
 
it's tough keeping a decent dink on a 32 footer, towing gets old very quickly since you always have to worry about the dink when docking.

the livingstons have very little freeboard and can swamp easily, and have low capacity ratings.

if you mostly need something to use around your home area and occasionaly tow, then any larger hard dink will do. i wouldn't bother with a rib if you're going to keep it in the water.. Whaler, Carolina Skiff, etc..

if you want to take it with you often, then maybe stern davits are best anda small RIB woudl work ?

i coudlnt' find anything stable enough with 6 pax so i built my own...
 
Thanks for the replies; really gives me some options to think about and research. My Beneteau Antares 9.80 has a unique feature in that the transom slides forward to provide a larger swim platform. Maybe davits can be installed to handle a dinghy. I like the looks of the Livingston and have also thought about the smallest Whaler as an option. My inflatable has not shown up yet, so I will need something to replace it.
 
do a search of Boss Boats, we had one for awhile, and now wish we had it back...light enough for flip davits or to hang on st croix davits, all fiberglass and positive floatation, looks like a rib, but is all glass... wish I'd never sold ours...

Good luck...
 
A dinghy with a flat bottom, square stern, good beam water line, and high bow, would be a reasonable skiff type of dinghy.

Do you have a brand name or ref. site of one of the above. By the way, I'm just now halfway through "River Horse" by Least Heat Moon in his c-dory 25.
 
Pascal. Being a Livingston owner I dont agree with your take.

This is a pic thats something over ten years past now. Towing my 10 foot behind the old 32 foot woodie. I also had the weaver davits to hang the Livingston on. However I prefer to tow 90 percent of the time. I used the weaver system for storage.

towing_0002.jpg


This be a typical spot I would anchor into too. The "beaches" on this coast are not so kind on the expensive type tenders. Tube boats and I dont seem to get along very well.

COPLANDSANCHORAGE.jpg


One thing I love about these boats is the interior room. Ya being hard means they dont have a ton of reserve bouyancy but you wont see peoples butts hangin over the sides. The load goes inside with lots of freeboard.

tender-1.jpg


This run would have bin about 15 miles turn around to pick up some family that were joining us for a few nights. Three adults two dogs with luggage. Its nice to have that ability being able to transport a good sized load. Again no butts sitting on the gunnels its all inside. Lots of freeboard, gets up and planes, nice and safe IMO.

DEADHEADSPITTDOG002.jpg


Not unusual for me to do a 10 to 20 mile run in 1 or 2 foot chop with ease. I have yet to sink one. I understand its possable but its just not bin my experience. Ya I have swamped it after it did the kite deal. But I just ran till most of the water bailed out on its own and finished the job with the bailing bucket. I coulda just pulled the plugs but bailing was faster.

I have also swamped it while towing. But no big deal it only takes on so much water then off loads it over the stern. When we hit calm water again I just bailed it out.

Both them times the cause was self inflicted.

They tow great. They have good freeboard. They are tough little boats. They are stable. Its a cat hull so they are even fast and run smooth. They dont realy bang or bounce like the whaler ride.

Just my take from like 15 years of owning them.

This is a 12T that I have placed too much power on. My choice.

I realy enjoyed the 10 with a 15 two stroke. Great for three to dive off. I even used it to transport off road motor bikes in. Not something you would do with a tube boat or whaler of this size.

DEADHEADSPITTDOG032.jpg


I like my little Livingston. Can ya tell. < grin >
 
yeah i can tell... :-) i know they're farily popular so they can't be that bad :-) i also think they come in different transom height, so maybe the taller ones have enough freeboard. Those i saw seem to ride very low in the water with just 2 on board!
 
Something I do see people doing with the 10 s and 12 foot Livingston models is loading them like they are tube boats. You do need to load them with some thought. I have seen guys out fit em with four stroke power electric start. Thats Ok but then they place the battery and fuel cell at the back along with some misc, stuff. Add the driver and wa la she is low in the stern. All it takes is to place that battery and fuel cell up front instead to level the boat. Just an example. You do need to think about how you load a Livingston for best trim. A tube boat will be more forgiving if loaded off trim a bit.
 
Ya I knew I be pushing the Dingy envelope a bit hard on this forum < grin >
 
I rescued a guy from a sinking Livingston on Keechelus lake in Washington state.
I never had any confidence in those Air Filled float chambers after that.

Joe thats a cute little Dingy but its tippy and wet inside. Getting in and out are trips down terror lane!
 
Thud

The older Livingstons had air in the chambers. Once some one put a screw or such threw them they be done. Not only would they not give you any floaty floaty action they would hold water adding weight to the deal. Not good. But thats an older boat.

The newer boats are foam filled and that includes the floor on my 12T

Will he ever stop LOL.

http://www.livingstonboats.com/

Nope I dont sell em have no connection with them boats unless I am in one. Then its a direct connection as I hang on.
 
Back
Top