Ethanol...spring engine startup

Two issues with ethanol in gas -- (1) compatibility with fuel system components on older boats, (2) water.

I posted a long analysis of the water issue. Basically, if your fuel source is sound and your system doesn't let water intrude then there should be no problem.

Compatibility is a bigger and costlier issue. And it's not just what's on your boat, it includes the whole supply chain. If it ran through an incompatible line or tank, then you may see problems that had nothing to do with your setup.

Recently, I have learned of a third problem - paranoid boat owners. In the last month I learned of three cases of "bad gas". After all was said and done it turned out it was the boat owner at fault - each had dumped all kinds of additives to try to prevent problems they weren't having, and ended up with problems. I saw one - brown goo separated and sank to he bottom. Turned out that after the fuel guy confronted him, the owner confessed he had added three different additives trying to make sure he wouldn't have problems (boat's on my same pier with me and we use the same gas). It ended up costing him about $2000.

According to two of the better fuel service folks in my area they say, take it as it comes out of the pump and run it. As long as your boat systems are compatible and sound, there should be little problem. According to them the recent experience has been that nervous boat owners are doing more to screw up their gas than anything they see from the supply side. Earlier reports of problems from fuel distribution have proven to be mostly owner induced problems.

Cobalt's gel problem has me intrigued. From everything I know it would suggest either a boat system incompatibility or fuel delivered through a distribution chain that had a compatibility problem. By now most of those should have been found and resolved.

Go easy on the additives - treat as you would for gas before ethanol.
 
Eric,

Your comment about "boat system incompatibility" perked my interest.

I used to have a Cobalt, hence the name.

In 2003 it cost roughly eight grand to resolve a problem that Formula and Mercruiser said was a result of "bad gas". In Massachusetts you can get a tax rebate on boat gas, so I saved all my receipts that year. I called each place and they claimed they had no issues with bad gas. Were they lieing? I doubt it. It seems to me that there would be other complaints as well, and word would get out. All the fuel was purchased within a twenty mile radius.

In my mind, I never believed it was bad gas. I believe that somehow water was introduced into the system. I wish I could access the archives of BoaterEd because I went through all this right here when it happened.

The interesting question is- is there a connection between my "bad gas" in 2003 and ethanol in 2006? Exactly the same amount of time elapsed in each occurance. What's gonna happen in 2009?

I wish I knew enough about this stuff to go back to Formula and Merc and tell them they were wrong, if in fact they were.

Peter
 
Peter,

What was their evidence or data supporting "bad gas"? If it was water that would , in IMHO, qualify as "bad gas". The questions is, how did it get there?

Water in gas in the pre-ethanol era typically was usually difficult pinpoint a source. The water would settle to the bottom and only a few customers would get the slug. The upshot was that it would often appear as isolated and would be difficult to pin on any one retail outlet because nobody else had the problem. I got nailed once in my car - filled up at the local Shell station - next day car would hardly run - found a lot of water in the tank. Went back to the Shell station - no help ... I was the only one with a problem so it couldn't be them.
 
My source of water? The Merc technician, when he first started looking at things, discovered a vacuum hose that was disconnected and hanging into the bilge. He contended that it was sucking up water into the fuel rails. Later he showed me the rusted and corroded fuel rails.

Merc hinted at Formula's installation being the problem. Formula hinted that it had never been installed at the factory. Guess which one assumed responsibility? Yeah, right!

One of them, I honestly forget which one, did send me a check for $750 for "customer relations".

I will never, after buying Merc products since 1978, buy a Merc product again.

Peter
 
That wasn't bad gas - that was either a faulty installation or a faulty part. If it was still under the warranty period I would have filed at least for the $5000 small claims limit (Texas law) naming whoever issued the engine warranty. It wouldn't have covered the total costs, but it is a good bit better than $750, and you can do it yourself.

Do you remember how the warranty was structured? Was it all Formula or did they hand you Mercury warranty on the engines like auto manufacturers do with tires?

I am with you - vote with your feet and take your wallet with you.
 
At the time, there was an extended warranty in effect issued by Formula but through another company.

You know, the more I think about this the less I want to. It's done, I believe I got screwed, and I need to move on.

But, as I said, I'll move on without Merc in my future.
 
The drama goes on with this. The way I see it the problem with ethanol is multi faceted. For one, the consumer cannot be sure of how much ethanol is in the gas they are using, and I have seen reports that it can be higher than the 10% considered OK. The oil companies are concerned enough about water absorbtion that they don't mix it and send it through their distrubition system, supposedly it is mixed in the tanker. Next, there is the compatibility issue with older fuel systems. Lastly, and this is probably the most difficult to change, the open fuel vent that all boats use (no vapor recovery like cars have had for 35 years) allows moisture to intrude. I had a reddish gel in the bottom of my fuel water seperating filter the first year. But I didn't have operational problems I could tie to ethanol. Subsequent filter changes revealed no gunk in the filter. I may switch to the Racor with the metal bowl for inboards so I can check it more easily.
 
Lou, how big a deal is it to sitch to the racors from the standard water sep filters? Do they "just spin on" to what we have now?????
 
Only big deal is they cost a lot more. They spin on the same way, looks like could hold more water, and I think they filter down to a smaller particle level. You have to use the metal bowl version if you have inboards. OBs can use the see thru plastic bowl.
 
I'm not sure that you can just spin them on. I mounted a whole new unit (about a hundred bucks) on a vertical wall in the engine compartment with the accompanying additional class A fuel hoses. It's not difficult, but you need to have enough room to get to the removable bottom piece. I bought a bronze petcock which makes it a lot easier to access and drain.

This unit is in addition to the stock Merc fuel filter. Once I installed this piece and drained it often, the problems went away. Damn, I probably shouldn't have said that!
 
I replaced the stock Merc "water separator" fuel filter with Racors on the strong recommendation of my mechanic. I think it was about $100 each. You need to replace the whole unit and then the filters are spin-on.
 
Since many more have launched their boats I curious with the outcome.
 
Following an exacting procedure developed over many, many years, I stored the boat exactly as we finished using it for the season (Albany NY) and when the boat was splashed yesterday, the '00 3.0 liter Mercruiser fired immediately and ran as it always had. The gasoline in the tank, about 1/2 full, had been carefully poured from our 11 gallon "gas pal" portable tank. The gas had been whatever the local Mobil dealer was pumping last September. The battery was a Walmart, fresh two years ago.
 
We have managed to get quite a few boats launched in the last few weeks. So far there have been no problems with any of the boats due to fuel. Some had full tank, others where low. When I launched I had approx. 1/4 of a tank..40 gals per tank and no problem. I ran a short trip with no problem. I just filled up the other day and took a 3 hour run afterwards. Nothing stirred up and ran great.

It seems like our idle time may not be enough for separation, time will tell...Hopefully everyone else out there has the same success story....
 
Launched last week and engines strated right up and ran well. Genset too! At storage, I had added the usual amount of Stabil and ran it through the engines. The i added the called for amount of Startron to the fuel tanks. i did not run the startron through. thsi is the forst year I have added the Startron. I want to run the boat for a few hours before I change the fuel water seps. I have never seen any water there before. I'll let you know this year.
Greg
 
We will have to refer to this thread next fall when the ethanol and tank levels come up again.
 
I kept my tanks full this year added startron and e-zorb I launched today without incident.Let the boating begin....
 
OK, stored with tanks half full, Stabil plus Startron. Ran the boat today on the old fuel. Both engines ran right up to max RPM without a problem and she ran well. I haven't changed the fuel water seps yet. I'd like to run a few hours before I change them to see what's in them.
Greg
 
Back
Top