The most trouble free type of inflator for these devices is the Halkey-Roberts inflator - generally uses a 33 to 50 gram C)2 cartridge, little green plastic 'ready' tab that breaks off when you pull the cord, attached to a lever that punctures the cylinder seal.
I use the belt pack type when I'm on any boat outside of work, kayaking, fishing, working (moonlighting), whatever. If you're using one of these devices, you really, really do need to try it out in the water - when it inflates, it feels like you're holding a float from underneath. Best way I can think of to describe it. Almost feels like it's pushing you backwards into the water until you get it over your head.
The regular inflatable PFD's provide significantly more buoyancy than a comparable foam type III or V, or the blocky type II's. I believe they have only slightly more buoyancy than a Type I, but I could be wrong. Could be way more. Problem is, foam is always buoyant, inflatables are only buoyant if the cylinder is intact, the inflator is intact and capable of opening the cylinder, and the bladdder is intact and capable of holding the pressure. No intrinisic buoyancy at all.
Now, I'm not knocking them. I use one of the 'sketchier' types of inflatable myself, and I have a more than passive knowledge about the factors influencing a person in the water's survival. But you do need to maintain these things. And that's the biggest doubt I have with the automatic models - are they really being maintained? If the bobbin degrades for whatever reason, will you really replace it every year or two? IS it REALLY going to automatically inflate? Did you repack it right? (Yeah, it MATTERS) Use the right size cylinder (different makes and models use different sizes)? Did it inadvertently fire when those darned green tabs inevitably broke off and you 'meant to rearm it but never got around to it'?
Compared to, is it made of foam? Is it there? Then it floats.
Just food for thought. Like I said, I'm not knocking them, just encouraging a little due diligence.