LED Navigation Lights

Nibbs

Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2006
RO Number
24454
Messages
103
I am a very frustrated with my Nav lights as they have been trouble prone over the years, so started looking into replacing them with LED lights. I am shocked by the prices! [:-bigeyes] Why are they so expensive? Any downsides to using LED as NAV lights? Are they as visible as regular lights? Your input is greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance!
 
Well, something new on the market with no competition sets the price right now. After they catch on, prices will drop.

I believe Nav Lights, regardless of the technology, must meet certain minimum requirements. I'd like to have them, but I think I'll wait until the prices are more reasonable.
 
If you look at the cost against longevity, plus the lower amperage use of the LEDs, they don't look so bad price wise.
 
Nibbs- Yes, by reg. they should be as bright as incandescents to be marketed for the same use and my LED's certainly are.

My old conventional festoon bulb Perko side lights required bulb replacement( using dielectric grease) at least a couple times a season ,each side, & occasional fixture replacement. Replaced with Perko's 602DP1CHR LED's over a year ago( 2yrs?) , taking care to seal the wires where they enter the module as well as the gasket with silicone. Zero maint. issues since- I love these things. Well worth it to me for these bright attractive lights and the module is easily accessible if they ever do need replacing and Perko does have replacement modules. Note: the ridged base gasket is a bit of a PIA to install as it has to be stretched slightly to fit properly while holding everything else in place with my other 2 hands, but doable. Also, since the + & - wires are sooo tiny compared to the original boat supply wiring gauge, slipping heat shrink over one side and soldering the splice, coating with dielectric grease , then shrinking may be a bit more feasible than normally recommended butt-connector crimping in this case.

I wish they would hurry up & come out with an LED overhead all-white rear Nav/all-around Anchor light combo on a short stalk so I could change that out also. I'd rather not just use replacement LED-festoons as I'd still have the vulnerable fixture contacts to rely on.

http://www.boatfix.com/bypage3.asp?page=109 .
 
I had the LED all around white. Imho, bulletproof and bright. Others observed that it was quite visible, esp relative to other lights. Used very little electricity relative to standard festoon. Red and green were "on the list of improvements".

Only downside was initial $$$.
 
I replaced my problematic 14 year old navigation lights with Aqua Signals series 32 Navigation LED fixtures. The fixtures and LEDs are all CG, ABYC, IMO, CE and RINA approved. The approvals especially CG were important to me and they came with documentation. Since my boat is technically over 40 feet I needed a masthead light in addition to the anchor light. I replaced all the navigation lights and they draw about 1/3 the current of the old lights and appear much brighter. They were very expensive but I am hoping that the lights will probably outlive the boat. The lights all have a nice look to them and operate on a wide range of voltages without varying intensity. I am very happy I bit the bullet and had them all replaced. Replacing the navigation lights is just part of an overall effort on my part to upgrade all my boat system's and reduce the overall current draw on my battery systems and engine charging systems. As a side note every interior light was upgraded to LED and any lights near the helm are dual red/white fixtures this was a huge current savings (46 fixtures in total). Take care. Bill
 
I upgraded mine last year. The only problem, they're so bright(especially the green) that the reflection off the side deck is a bit too intense.

I've considered putting shields on them to keep the reflected light down without changing the angle of visability.

RWS
 
RWS

Maybe line the inside with a piece of waxed paper. Is it worth the trouble to do that?
 
It's not the brightness, but rather the splashed light reflected back into the cockpit area from the deck.

A 90 dggree plastic angle and velcro would work but not look too nice. I need to come up with a better idea.

Other than that, they're great.

RWS
 
Regardless of what light you choose, I'd suggest you not use the "Crimp" type junctures. Much better to solder them and use shrink tubing for insulation. Any mechanical means of connection in areas exposed to weather or moisture is prone to corrosion and circuit difficulty. Sandy has it right.
 
I would not use solder in a marine environment, it in itself can be corrosive in salt air and it can take flexabilty away from the marine grade wire when it wicks back under the insulation. Use the correct heat shrink crimps with the proper tool. I am not sure about others but most of my navigation light fixtures wires terminate inside the boats structure and are not subject to the elements. The only lights where this may not be the case are my masthead and anchor light but the wiring is inside my radar arch. I haven't had any problems using the correct heat shrink crimp connectors. This is just my opinion.
Regards Bill
 
The LED lights are worth every penny IMHO. Brighter, longer lasting, no aggravating bulb replacements and less drain on the circuit.

One word of caution to all that may have them-reduce the fuse size in the circuit! Since they require less draw, reduce the size of the fuse in the circuit if you have them installed as replacements. Typically, a 10 amp fuse should now be be reduced to a 5 or even less!

Being electronic devices, the LEDS can malfunction and they can generate a lot of heat even at lower amperage draws!. There have been some reports of these LEDS starting fires when in contact with combustibles on board!

These are no more numerous than electrical fires caused by conventional incandescent bulbs, but why take a chance? Just reduce the fuse to as low an amp rating as possible.
 
The LED lights themselves give off very little heat. The heat is generated by the voltage regulator circuit board. I haven't read any incidents of LED lights causing a fire. My older halogen lights had black marks in the interior from excessive heat, but the old fixtures were cracked which I believe allowed the heat to get behind the fixture. I noticed this when I was replacing the ceiling lights in my boats interior.

You are absolutely correct about changing the fuse size especially if you replaced (reduced) the wire size the fuse needs to protect the wire as well.
 
Great input on reducing the size of the fuse, although it complicates my plans greatly as I will have to replace all of the lights on the nav light circuit, not just the pretty red and green ones (i.e. the transom light and the anchor light).
 
if it's not an approved light, you may have some trouble if you have an accident and some one notices. Use red and green LED's under the red and green lense, the white ones will show pink and blue or some shade other. I want a BIG light not some little marble on the bow. I want people to know what I am doing.
 
"Approved Light" is key here. That will assure that the range, arc of visibility, and as just mentioned, color quality are all addressed. If the LED in a colored nav light has to be replaced, the replacement will likely have to be colored also. That's something we're not used to with incandesent bulbs.
 
It makes no sense whatsoever to place a white LED in a fixture when you need red ( or Green ). The monochromatic LEDs are more efficient, cheaper, maintain their output longer, And, oh yea, produce ( only ) the desired color. It makes no sense to jump through expensive chemical hoops to produce a white LED lamp, only to turn about and filter out 60%+ of the light to get red ( or green ). Use the monochromatic lamp in the first place.

--

Yes, "Approved" is the key word here.
 
The cost probably won't be coming down anytime soon. LED tail lights have been available to the trucking and trailer industries for years. When you look at the cost of an oval or round incandescent sealed replacement and a LED sealed replacement the LED is still 3-4 times as expensive, but the reliability and longevity of the LED is worth the cost!
 
quote:

One word of caution to all that may have them-reduce the fuse size in the circuit! Since they require less draw, reduce the size of the fuse in the circuit if you have them installed as replacements. Typically, a 10 amp fuse should now be be reduced to a 5 or even less!






If you are just changing the fixture, or lamp to LED, there is no need to reduce the fuse size. The fuse is there to protect the wiring. If you reduce the wire size, then you must reduce the fuse size.

I replaced my nav lights with NEW incandesant lights. The old nav lights had corroded sockets and the lenses were hazed over. I couldn't justify the cost of the LED nav lights. I paid less than $40 for the pair.
2168811690102200758S600x600Q85.jpg
 
whatever you use, make sure teh arc is correct. there are many boats out there where you can see the green and red beyond the arc.
 
Back
Top