Whale Wars rant

Kerry,

Again, your post makes little sense for the reasons that are in the follow-up posts. Plus, you indicate that the nutjobs are making progress because they are raising the awareness of the Japanese population. So, are you now also claiming that the Japanese are watching Whale Wars??? Have you ever been to Japan??
 
Greenpeace no longer goes to the southern oceans to harass the whaling fleet because they realized after years of doing it the Japanese felt that their traditions were being attacked and became more supportive of whaling if anything. They decided instead to concentrate on working with Japanese politicians and trying to change the thinking in Japan towards protecting the whales. This definitely goes against the idea that the Sea Shepards are helping anything. Did you see when they interviewed the Japanese translator who volunteers on the boat? She wanted her identity protected because she said the Japanese people consider them terrorists and didn't want anyone to know she had anything to do with them. The idea that the Sea Shepards are raising awareness in Japan and getting people to boycott whale meat is the opposite of everything I've read.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PeteMrrs

Kerry;;

If nobody is eating the whale meat, . . . AND. . . . the whalers have more meat in storage than they know what to do with, Why would they continue to expend money and suffer aggrivation to harvest more?

Would you please back up this claim?






Yes very good point isn't it? I ask the same question, don't know the answer either.
 
quote:

Originally posted by two_rocks

What is Norway's quota? MORE than the Japanese I think.

Harvesting food from the wild can only go on so long; in the end we will indirectly out eat them and they are doomed.

As far as the whale whores, I watch any show with water and boats.






NO definately not more than the Japanese. Norway is about a 1:3 ratio with the Japs but one could argue that Norway has "increased" numbers since the mid 90's only because Norway stoppped whaling in the mid 90's and re-started, the Japs they haven't let up.

To a point the Japs appear to have this use it or loose it mentality regardless of what is stockpiled?
 
quote:

Originally posted by MikeeH

Kerry,

Again, your post makes little sense for the reasons that are in the follow-up posts. Plus, you indicate that the nutjobs are making progress because they are raising the awareness of the Japanese population. So, are you now also claiming that the Japanese are watching Whale Wars??? Have you ever been to Japan??






All the nutcases don't go to the antartic you know, they actually lobby at the point of most impact as well, fairly obvious hey? get em at both ends.
 
Kerry;

Your reply was very confusing. I will try to make it a little clearer.

You stated: "Now the Japanese people are boycotting whale meat AND the Japs have more whale meat in storage than they know what to do with . . . "
Would you please explain how you know these "facts", or at least offer some documentation to back your claim.

Kapeash!!
 
As the one who introduced the word "eco-terrorist" to this thread, I feel I should comment...

First, I'm not the one who came up with this definition, though I feel that is is mildly appropriate.

Further, this is actually a discussion of several topics, not just one:

1) The show itself stinks. It almost certainly does not represent "reality", and promotes not only "bad behavior", but poor seamanship.

2) There is the issue of international relations. Ir has always been an "iffy" proposition. Treaties are only valid till one party changes their mind. There is no real enforcement, and in fact, there are few methods of enforcement that are preferable to the infraction.

3) The topic of how a country holds to it's agreements. In this case, Japan "won" a "right" via international treaty and is exercising it.

4) Whaling, in general. I am against it. Period.

--

If you do not like what Japan is doing, then approach the problem via a forum that might actually have some effect: the UN. Irritating professional seaman who are carrying out their duties is rather pointless, and dangerous.

If you do not like the show, ( or for that matter, the organization that is the focus of the program ), a) quit watching, b) complain to the broadcaster and also to their sponsors.

If you do not like how international relations function, sadly you will be an unhappy person for a long time. This is typical of how it works, and it has been like this for a very long time. There is little chance that it will ever change. This is as good as it gets.

And as far as the word "eco-terrorist" is concerned, I believe it was coined by the media, and has been applied to such things as spiking trees and nuclear powerplant operation disruptions. The word itself is likely too strong for most of the situations where it is used. Please feel free to offer a substitute that the media will accept and use...

btw, and, imho, if there was no TV program, the activity would almost certainly stop. The whole point is to inflame public opinion ( and, of course, suck in viewers ). There are better, more effective, and more responsible ways to "get the word out".

In any event, having watched all of, perhaps 10 minutes, of the program, I determined that I did not fit the "viewer profile" and turned it off. I chose to do something useful and productive with my ( limited and irreplaceable ) time. Perhaps others should consider the same.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PeteMrrs

Kerry;

Your reply was very confusing. I will try to make it a little clearer.

You stated: "Now the Japanese people are boycotting whale meat AND the Japs have more whale meat in storage than they know what to do with . . . "
Would you please explain how you know these "facts", or at least offer some documentation to back your claim.

Kapeash!!






"Recent Polls show that less than 1% of the Japanese public regularly eats whale or dolphin meat and only 11% of Japanese public supports whaling while over 77% oppose it. "
 
Kerry - I spent a couple hours trying to find proof of your assertion that the Japanese people do not want whale meat. I did find the quote verbatim of what you posted "Recent Polls show that less than 1% of the Japanese public regularly eats whale or dolphin meat and only 11% of Japanese public supports whaling while over 77% oppose it. " from an anti whaling site and dated Feb 2006. This site has no supporting documentation nor does it say how the information was obtained. But hey, its on the internet so it must be true right?

Bottom line is: No demand no need for supply. The only way to curtail whaling is eliminate the want to consume it. That want is deeply ingrained in a 1000s year old culture. I would like to see whaling come to an end also but doing the things the members of the Steve Irwin are doing are nothing short of criminal and will only strengthen the resolves of people who consider it a part of their heritage.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PeteMrrs

Kerry;

Your reply was very confusing. I will try to make it a little clearer.

You stated: "Now the Japanese people are boycotting whale meat AND the Japs have more whale meat in storage than they know what to do with . . . "
Would you please explain how you know these "facts", or at least offer some documentation to back your claim.

Kapeash!!






You should have been a politician that keeps going around in ever continuing circles saying less and less about nothing and keep asking how long is a foot of string.

But just to "please" your continual circle tracking and going no where I will try and find this source again. Then of course you still won't be happy will you? But then that's typical in this type of discussion.

So did man really walk on the moon?
 
Kerry;

No circle tracking, I just believe that if you post something as being true, then there should be away of verifying it. Otherwise it carries no value.

I love the whales, and I don't think that they should be slaughtered, but I don't believe that the Japanesse are breaking the law. They most certainly are streching it for all it's worth but that's not illeagal. If they were breaking it I would expect the nations of the world to come down hard on them. Not Paul Watson.

Hell most of us stretch every rule we can in our business and personal lives. As long as you understand the boundries and stay within them it's called the competitve edge.

I also wonder why the life of a whale is any more valuable then that of a penguin, baby seal or sand slug for that matter.

BTW: Man really did walk on the moon. I sat up all night long and watched the lunar rover sitting on the moon.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

Originally posted by PeteMrrs

Kerry;

Your reply was very confusing. I will try to make it a little clearer.

You stated: "Now the Japanese people are boycotting whale meat AND the Japs have more whale meat in storage than they know what to do with . . . "
Would you please explain how you know these "facts", or at least offer some documentation to back your claim.

Kapeash!!
<hr height="1" noshade id="quote"></font id="quote"></blockquote id="quote">

"Recent Polls show that less than 1% of the Japanese public regularly eats whale or dolphin meat and only 11% of Japanese public supports whaling while over 77% oppose it. "





Where was that poll taken? LICC Forum?
 
Frankly it's not hard to search for stuff on this but then I suppose it all depends on what you find doesn't suit "your" thinking.

In FACT there is so much of this stuff around from so many different sources that you would find difficult to ignore but then again with some people it wouldn't matter how much was staked against them the blinkers go on.

So who is going to be the first to claim teh world has a conspiracy towards the Jap's own stupidity ??

Anyway I like the one where they are pushing whale for pet food, nice one hey can't even give the stuff away

http://www.japanprobe.com/?p=27

But wait there's more pet food

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,22959881-30417,00.html

And from another paper

Rotting whale meat mountain

By Lauren Williams

February 13, 2008 01:40am
Article from: The Daily Telegraph

* Japan's whalers going broke
* Force to slash prices over unwanted whale meat
* "Further proof of no market for whale market"

JAPAN's whalers are going broke and have been forced to slash prices because no one wants to eat their growing mountain of whale meat.

The farcical truth of Japan's whaling industry was exposed yesterday by Japanese media reports that the Institute for Cetacean Research is struggling to repay $37 million in government subsidies.

The report came as Japanese embassy officials made a stern prïtest in Canberra over the Federal Government's release of shocking whaling photographs.

The ICR, responsible for Japan's lethal "research operation", is flooding Japan with cheap whale meat that it cannot sell, according to the reports in respected newspaper Asahi Shimbun.

Meat and other parts of whales killed during ICR "scientific research" in the Southern Ocean is sold to a private fisheries company Kyodo Senpaku, which manages the sale of whale meat in the Japanese market. But while ICR has consistently increased the number of whales it kills – by 30 per cent between 2005 and 2006 – there has been no rise in domestic demand for whale meat or products.

Greenpeace Australia Pacific whales campaign director Rob Nicholl said the losses were further proof that there was no market for whale meat in Japan.

"It's standard economics. There is an oversupply. They've had to reduce the price but they still can't get rid of the stuff," he said.

Japan has consistently argued a case for scientific whaling and last week accused the Government and Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade of "misleading" the public by releasing photographs of the slaughter of whales in the Southern Ocean.

A DFAT spokesman said, while the photographs were "disturbing, they were in no sense misleading".
 
quote:

Originally posted by PeteMrrs

BTW: Man really did walk on the moon. I sat up all night long and watched the lunar rover sitting on the moon.






Hell I watched it on TV too, live so it must be right :) hey so stuff on moon = man walked there too? Come on now you going to have to prove that, I want some FACTS.

Geez we want proof, we could start a conspiracy on this, hell someone already did :)
 
Kerrt: I gave you proof. First hand account!! I saw it with my own two lying eyes!!

I even have a moon rock.

:)
 
If the Whale Wars Show is real, Its an embarrassment to the USA.

The reason I said "if its real" is because after watching 10 episodes of "Operation Repo" I found out that it was all re-enactments of events that have happened over the years to other repo guys.

I almost have to question if the Jap ship (as in 1 ship) they are chasing around each week is not just a ship that gets painted with thew word "research" on the side and a new name in Japanese on the stern. Also we really have no proof that anything the Steve Irwin throws is nothing more than taped up water balloons.

I think the Captain is completely stoned either on weed or pain killers and the crew, well they are just plain stupid and remind me of cult followers ready to drink the kool-aid when the Captain gives the order.

I hear the same recording off every Jap ship on the PA system and each Jap ship just plods along letting the Steve Irwin do anything they want. Seems a bit staged to me.

The Jap ship could easily throw a net over and foul the Steve Irwins props, they have a hundred opportunities each show to do it...but it never happens.

One net, would stop the Irwin from the chase and the Japs could continue fishing for the rest of the day.

Also how is it that the Jap ships can always be caught by the Irwin? No matter how far away the Jap ships are the Irwin always catches up and over takes them and its not like the Jap ships have nets out, they are just lurking along singing a song while the "Irwin" dances all around them like that cartoon about the Big dog and little dog "Spike & Chester".

That whole show is probably filmed off the coast of California (within 5 miles of CA) and at the end of the day both ships are tied up at the pier and its Miller Time.

I am also surprised that the Irwin family would allow Steve's name to be used in such an embarrassing way but I guess keeping his name up in lights is good for his estate / family.

My apologies to any Japanese members here for my use of the word Jap instead of Japanese...its just faster to type the JAP.
 
quote:

Originally posted by JLC

If the Whale Wars Show is real, Its an embarrassment to the USA.





Its amazing how the USA gets blames for everything! Could you please tell me how this is an embarrassment to the USA?
  • Is the Steve Irwin a US flagged vessel? NO, she flies the Dutch flag.
  • Does the Steve Irwin have a home port on US soil? NO, her home port is Australia
  • Aren't the Sea Shepherd's based in the US? The Sea Shepherds website indicates a US office, but also lists several others in other countries.
  • Aren't the Sea Shepherd vessels crewed by US citizens? The vessels are crewed by anyone stupid enough to sign on.
So someone please tell me how they are the US's embarrassment!

Edited for: lack of subject/verb tense agreement that was driving me nuts!
 
Phily,

The embarrassment to me is that the show is aired in America and we're dumb enough to watch it. :)

Bob

quote:

Originally posted by Philyteach

quote:

Originally posted by JLC

If the Whale Wars Show is real, Its an embarrassment to the USA.





Its amazing how the USA gets blames for everything! Could you please tell me how this is an embarrassment to the USA?
  • Is the Steve Irwin a US flagged vessel? NO, she flies the Dutch flag.
  • Does the Steve Irwin have a home port on US soil? NO, her home port is Australia
  • Aren't the Sea Shepherd's based in the US? The Sea Shepherds website indicates a US office, but also lists several others in other countries.
  • Isn't the Sea Shepherd crewed by US citizens? The vessels are crewed by anyone stupid enough to sign on.
So someone please tell me how they are the US's embarrassment!






 
Back
Top