Whale Wars rant

quote:

Originally posted by Kerry

......... teh world has a conspiracy towards the Jap's own stupidity ?? ......






Kerry,

I can't give your opinions much respect or validity as long as you keep refering to the Japanese people as "Japs".

Is you issue with the whaling or with people from a different race or culture?
 
English is spoken in many parts of the world and by many people... including the English ;). Its also the universally accepted language which is why all pilots flying internationally must speak English. Finally, its called "speaking English", not "speaking American".
 
quote:

Originally posted by rawidman

quote:

Originally posted by Kerry

......... teh world has a conspiracy towards the Jap's own stupidity ?? ......






Kerry,

I can't give your opinions much respect or validity as long as you keep refering to the Japanese people as "Japs".

Is you issue with the whaling or with people from a different race or culture?








So you now trying to justify your tunnel vision thoughts and not accepting the opinions and facts because of What? You need to move on if that is all you have to counter the discussion commnets, opinions and facts.

No different to Americans being Yanks and the British are Poms and so on, move on.
 
Except you have not provided any facts, only dated articles from slanted sources. Or, put in simpler terms, I do not belive your sources.
 
FWIW, The Japanses call us Gai Jin. Not a totally flattering term either.

Chinese call us Gwai Lo. Not exactly flattering either.

Bob
 
Sorry Mike I was being sarcastic. It does seem though that if you are white, protesting something, and speak english than they do label them as Americans and we all take the blame.

It matters not what a race or culture calls me I try to take the high road and refer appropriately to other cultures. That being said, folks from my dads generation have a different take on the world with regard to the Japanese people.

And Kerry, you have not offered any facts. I can come up with a sample poll of Japanese people that say 8 out of 10 still eat whale meat and thank the whalers for providing it. Your stated facts come from a source that is anti whaling and highly suspect. Not to mention that they are dated. I also argree with others point about your hipocrasy. Where is your outrage at other countries that are whaling? Why are the whales the only water bourne mammal that rates protection? What about dolphins? What about seals? Others?

While many environmentalist groups are well intentioned, to many simply jump on the save something band wagon because they "want to do something outragous" or "get noticed". They do not have a noble cause in mind other than to force others to their belief. If they did they would see the big picture and persue it accordingly.

Look up Rosevelt's Grand Canyon deer.

Sorry for the rant - and spelling.
 
I think this thread has possibly gotten more entertaining that the show :)

As for "proof" of statistics, I completely agree that unless the source is named and the research can be looked up, then then I will remain skeptical, no matter what the topic is. I remember my son about 7 yrs ago when he was 10 yrs old, and told me very matter of factly one day that if it is written, and he was referring to the internet, then it must be true! He is now 17 going on 30, knows everything in the world, still argues with me, but concedes he was wrong on that point!
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

Except you have not provided any facts, only dated articles from slanted sources. Or, put in simpler terms, I do not belive your sources.






Typical comments and as predicted, some people will argue about petty attitudes and simply refuse to believe anything anybody put in front of them.

Frankly when comments like this start appearing you know the person hasn't got a dam clue, absolutely no counter argument and trying to hind behind their own inabilities to accept the actual issues.

So did man actually walk on the moon?
 
Yes it does appear the subject has been adulterated but then that was expected and predicted as it really would not matter what you put in front of some people from whatever source they would still claim ignorance.
 
"No different to Americans being Yanks and the British are Poms and so on, move on."

Yanks is pretty neutral. Pommy is a derogatory term started by Australians for the English.

"FWIW, The Japanses call us Gai Jin. Not a totally flattering term either."

Gaijin. I believe they call all non-Japanese that. As I recall it just means non-Japanese or an "outside person". And it is not always derogatory.
 
Kerry;

My Ozzie friend, I really hate being "talked down" to.

If you really believe; " . . . that was expected and predicted as it really would not matter what you put in front of some people from whatever source they would still claim ignorance." Why do you even bother trying to communicate with us uneducated Americans, after all we have only been around for a couple hundred years, and could not expect to understand.

If you have such rage why don't you go join Capt Paul when he comes in for refueling
 
Now all the doubters have to do is prove (since they don't believe much) that the comments are in fact incorrect, wrong or whatever tag they want to put on them, did someone say they are not facts?

So first cab off the rank is the over supply of whale meat. If you don't agree then prove it!

That the Japanese have had to sell whale meat for pet food due to over supply and low prices due to stockpiling. If you don't agree then you prove it otherwise!

The Japanese whaling association are struggling to replay millions in subsidies. If you don't agree then you prove it otherwise!

So if anybody does not agree with the data and facts put forward then it's simple, you prove otherwise! No point in commenting unless you can prove otherwise. Your call :)

After this lot then then there will be more but somehow I doubt anybody will be able to prove any of the above comments wrong as some have unduly claimed.
 
"...If you don't agree then you prove it otherwise!" -- Kerry

"That the Japanese have had to sell whale meat for pet food due to over supply and low prices due to stockpiling. If you don't agree then you prove it otherwise!"

I neither agree, disagree, nor care. My cats might, but their canned food does not list whale meat as an ingredient.

"The Japanese whaling association are struggling to replay millions in subsidies. If you don't agree then you prove it otherwise!"

Then you should, by your own statements, be happy. The venture is failing. In any event, I do not invest in whale meat futures, so it means little to me, accurate or not.

"So if anybody does not agree with the data and facts put forward then it's simple, you prove otherwise! No point in commenting unless you can prove otherwise. Your call :)

Actually, you have made no case for me to disprove... you data that you present already makes the case that I need do nothing. It is -your- argument that we should do something. We have stated what is required to get our attention; you have not done so. We, on the other hand, having already had this discussion, have studied the matter and come to the following conclusions:

The show is a mind-numbing waste of time.

If, in fact, the activities of the "Sam Irwin" are being reported upon accurately, most of what is being shown represents at the very best, poor seamanship. Most of us feel that the boat and this crew should remain tied up in ( dry ) dock.

Some people legally hunt whales.

Some people think hunting whales is not a good idea, legal or not.

The legality of whale hunting is founded upon international treaties, ( all of which ) which have never been strictly honored, and, at this time, are not being enforced. This is because there is no mechanism to enforce the whaling treaty, and because, due to clever lobbying and wording of the treaty, what the Japanese ( and a few other groups/countries ) are doing is allowed by the treaty.

Now, if you want to promote a "save the whales" campaign then you need to find a different forum to do it in. This is a boating forum, not a save the protected species forum. If you wish to discuss the seamanship, or lack thereof displayed on the program, then knock yourself out; that's why we are here.

From a boating perspective, the Japanese vessel appears, in all respects, to be adhering to the letter of law, while the other vessel repeatedly appears to violate most laws of the sea, as well as common sense and courtesy.

---

So, kerry, how do you feel about the seamanship displayed in the program?
 
Seamanship? Who changed the subject :) Or were you talking about the de-registering of Japanese whaling vessels because they flaunt and defy the law. Wonder why nobody wants to take this de-registration issue head on or do you all agree on this one? Hmm

Thank heavens your not debating anything or maybe that's a good thing. Anyway the facts are there, don't like them then tuff
 
"Wonder why nobody wants to take this de-registration issue head on"

Because it is irrelevant to the type of boating we do perhaps.

And frankly, why do you care if the ship was de-registered, regardless of reason?

I really think you should take your "save the species" discussion someplace where most of the forum is actually interested in your "data".

The whole point I am making is that this is a site for boating education. Not for promoting my favorite causes, ( of which I have a few, as well ). You want "somebody" to "make" the Japanese ( only ) stop hunting whales. I've got it. Really. I do get it. And, as I have said before, I think there should be -no- whaling. It is a good plan. It is also not only impractical in this world that we live in, the it is unlikely that it will ever come to pass. After all, look at the status of the treaties on ivory, and endangered wood species. The same case can be made.

SO, back to boating:

Obviously, if you own a commercial vessel, it is important to follow the rules closely. And as far as I can tell, from the program ( remember: the original post was about the program... ) the Japanese vessel has observed the letter of the law, whereas the other vessel has not.
 
Oh how convenient, very selective aren't we but why doesn't that surprise me :)
 
Kerry, considering that you seem fixated on the Japanese taking of whales, and since you seem to think they are the only ones, I will refer you to the International Whaling Commission, where they present the allowed catches by species and geographical area. Note, the Japan is only one country of several, including the USA, Norway, Iceland, and, oh yes, Japan.

With that I'm dome. The thread clearly has little to do with boating, and I am losing interest...
 
So do tell me why a country such as Panama which is a flag of convenience country actually de-registered (let me say that again DE_REGISTERED) Japanese whaling vessels, say do you thing they might have been doing something illegal? Oh shock horror Japan whalers doing something illegal, well not according to Bill but then Bill doesn't want to understand the whole story.

So what do you reckon Bill? Why would Panama de-register Japanese whaling vessels? Don't want to know do you Bill?
 
Back
Top