Windlass or not?

lil red truck

Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
RO Number
25758
Messages
593
We've been back and forth with this here in our house, so let me ask you folks. How much better would life be with a windlass? Is it just one more thing to fret about and to go funky? I know it'll mean moving some things around in the cabin. If I get the job done in a yard what kind of warranty can I expect? Thanks.
 
Essential! I'd be divorced without a windlass---which is FAR more expensive than an anchor puller-upper! :-)
 
Yes on the windlass.

I had a Commercial Halibut operation for Five years and used an electric windlass the whole time.

IMHO a windlass is better for control when your working than a winch. I never had any trouble with the windlass or the wiring. I wired it in with a 30 Amp breaker (cant remember the wire size now, but if your yard knows what they are doing they will have it sized correctly)
 
a windlass is a must. make sure they wire it with heavy enough wire.
 
You really don't mention why you want a windlass. I have owned boats in that size and it seems a bit of overkill, but was curious if you had a specific set of reasons.
 
it's an overkill on a boat your size unless you encounter conditions where you really need it... ex... single handling the boat and anchoring in close quarter and windy conditions, where you want to be at the helm to control the boat.

in the late 80s, I live on St Barths in the Carib and the only dock there required med mooring. Since i was usually singlehandling, I had to control the rode while backing to the dock so i added a windlass.

it' wasn't too hard to install. I don't know if the anchor locker is setup the same way on your boat (mine was an 85 2550) but one problem was that the locker was too shallow resulting in the rode not feeding properly. I'd have to go to the bow every 30 or 40' and push it aside, not ideal.

you'll have to see where your anchor locker is... the 2550 was off center, with just a corner on cetnerline to feed the rode. if yours is not on centerline, you're going to have a problem feeding the rode in the locker. Mine had a bow pulpit which required no modification for the danforth to self launch.

if you don't have to modify the locker, it might be worth it, otherwise too much work...
 
I have to agree with PascalG--on your vessel, for most circumstances (eg rough weather), a windlass is an overkill. My first 2 vessels (22' and 26') did not have a windlass and my family and I didn't miss it. Hauling the anchor on those vessels was quite easy. ONt the other hand on my present vessel (34') it is absolutely manditory.
 
Yesh - that's why I asked. Didn't know if the bow was difficult to get to, had back problems, mate hates pulling up the anchor, etc.
 
Thanks guys.
jrekemeyer, I had reconstructive surgery on my shoulder last year, but I'm definitely getting stronger. Getting older too, and hope to do more of that.
Pascal, I usually am single handling. I was thinking that in the event of trouble in rough water, I'd want to be able to deploy w/o venturing on to the bow.
There's a bow pulpit. There's no existing locker, so installing one would be one task, at least I can have it placed where it will be most efficient. There's enough room in the bow to do that.
Thanks guys.
 
If you do add one you will not avoid the trip to the bow in rough water. The rode must be secured to a cleat once the anchor is set or you will damage the windlass. This project sounds like more trouble than it is worth. Having said that, I would not purchase a boat without a windlass because it is so useful and makes deploying the anchor a "piece of cake".
 
You may also want to consider how much anchoring you plan on doing. If it's just once or twice a season, why bother? I didn't drop my anchor even once this year and I've put about 150 hours on her, mostly cruising, drift fishing and trolling...
 
A windlass is one of those things...once you have one, you love it. And shiver me timbers but I never secure to the cleat...works for me.

On the last boat, it was a pain to retrieve the anchor (usually at croton point) if there was any wind...especially if it was coming out of the north and blowing me toward the beach or if you need a bit of power to disloge. I'd move the boat up a bit, run to the pulpit, retrieve as much as possible, tie it off, back to shifters, move up a bit, etc.

Re-phrase the question....is there anyone who has a windlass that think it's unnecessary?
 
...a pain to retrieve the anchor (usually at croton point) if there was any wind...especially if it was coming out of the north and blowing me toward the beach or if you need a bit of power to disloge. I'd move the boat up a bit, run to the pulpit, retrieve as much as possible, tie it off, back to shifters, move up a bit, etc.

Walshie- you perfectly and exactly illustrated another reason this has been on my mind. I'm back and forth on this mostly trying to justify the cost/benefit to myself. Truth be told, I'd also like to be able to go anchor in that "special place" across from Croton with out fretting.
 
the 2450 doens't have an anchor locker ? so were do you keep your rode ?
that may be better actually if you want to add a windlass, you shoudl be able to build one over the Vee berth, as far forward as possible not take up any space below.

walshie, frankly, on a 25 footer, i'd be fine without a windlass as long as i don't have to anchor in crowded anchorages or med moor alone. under 30', it's pretty easy to pull the boat forward by hand, as long as you have a good pulpit/roller, that's what makes a difference.

Over 30' with a good wind, then yes, it's a real workout...
 
Pascal, I hand wrap the rode onto a spool that is secured to the aft section of the bow pulpit.
 
quote:

Originally posted by sbw1

If you do add one you will not avoid the trip to the bow in rough water. The rode must be secured to a cleat once the anchor is set or you will damage the windlass. This project sounds like more trouble than it is worth. Having said that, I would not purchase a boat without a windlass because it is so useful and makes deploying the anchor a "piece of cake".






I do not secure my line to the cleat once the anchor is set.
 
Hey lil red truck,

Here is the real question. Do you need this for you? If for health reasons as mentioned above, then I guess your decision is made for you.

However, don’t add this item thinking you will recoup a significant portion of the expense via added resale value. It will add very little to the resale value of the boat.

A basic windlass is $1,500. Say you add a hawspipe and locker in the cabin, and can do this for another $500. Add another $500 for the wires, hardware and remote control so you can operate this from the helm and at the bow. This assumes you do the work.

You just added $2,500 in investment to an $8,000 boat.

So it comes down to ‘is this needed for you to boat?’ If so, the cost is not the object.
 
Honora, did Mike or Butch give you a key to get into that "special place"?
Pascal, my last boat was a 28'er and true, most of the time, it was a pain but relatively easy to pull the anchor when alone and no wind. But, if it's set in the mud, I'd have to cleat it then break it with the engines by driving forward (danforth).

Also, while we haven't met, I seem to recall Honora being of the estrogen type...you know an egg layer...the type of creature that bleads for eight days straight and still lives! Therefore, she might not be as strong as you or I, especially with a bum shoulder.

FWIW, two boats ago I had a...Bayliner 2450 with a windlass...nice option - go for it...talk to the guys at PB, the boys from the left coast love their mechanics.
 
Back
Top