Anchors

yzer & Pascal,

Thank you both for the insight. I'll be doing some research (and with the very mild Fall up here, maybe some testing).

Pascal - "a cat present more surface to the wind than a monohull". I'm not quite sure what you mean by that. We certainly have less surface & resistance below waterline due to how shallow we are (18" draft). But we also technically have 60' of waterline. In my experience, we do better with wind than most monohulls. But I've heard the comment before, so please let me know what it is I'm missing. When we've been on our old 13# steel fluke anchor with 15' chain and 10:1 scope and 30-40 knot winds have picked up, we don't budge. Don't forget, when we are at anchor and the wind is on our bow(s), we're hollow down the middle! :-)

Oh, and must note that our rollers are off the port bow, and at a bit of a port angle. So having an anchor that's too wide will end up really catching a ton of pilings on that side!

yzer - thanks for that link. I'll be reading up on those Danforth models. But wouldn't you call those "fluke" style anchors you linked to? Unless I'm way off base, that link showed me flukes with "Danforth" stamped on the side.

Thanks folks!
 
Yes Kurt, you are absolutely right: the Danforth is a fluke anchor. For some strange reason I was confusing claw anchors with the flukes. The correct statement is: Danforth never made a plow or claw anchor.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchor
 
I agree with yzer but want to add a bit! Notice that he did not say he tossed the anchor overboard then backed down from it! Setting the anchor on the bottom carefully and not allowing the rode to pile on top is something that one should always be aware of. I like to stop after letting out about 1/4 of the intended rode, let it set for a bit give it a tug, pay out another 1/4 and repeat. Then pay out the rest of the rode. That helps the flukes dig in and also gives you a bit of warning should it have snagged a rock or be in vegetation. As for anchor size. Buy all you can handle. Reccomended size is one thing but double is better! More chain means more weight.
 
to follow larry b --- i usually let out approx 1/2 of intended scope and gently back down until my chain starts to tighten, let out another 10' do the same and repeat a few times until i reach desired scope. i contantly do little tugs as i set it, then once i am at desired scope, cleat it off (remember never leave the weight on the windlass) and throw both motors in reverse, throttle up to 1000+/- rpm and make sure it does not move!
 
Thanks guys. I appreciate the input.

It's funny how boats are different. TCIJOE - 1000 RPM for me is IDLE! (twin Honda 50 OBs!)

We always back the chain/rode out. I too have seen the 3:1 scope idiots. So far (knock on wood), we've never had a problem (other than sometimes needing a bit of power to dig the anchor back out!). And no cleating with chain on this boat. I've got a good nylon bridle system set up. The nylon takes the shocks. Should it fail, the anchor lock takes over. Then, the windlass is on it's own (it's held us in a 40 knot blow one time).

Hmmm, but "double is better". Yes, I do agree. But not really feasible on a 30', at least not mine the way she's set up. I'll up-size somehow for sure though.

Thanks again!
 
mixman, i use a "snubber" line....i am sure very similar to your bridal. i did not mean that i literally cleat the chain off....man that would put a heck of a strain on any cleat, probably jerk me around on a windy night too!
 
interesting... i always deploy whatever scope i will need and then check set with the engines. I'm not sure i see why you woudl want to attempt setting it before all you scope is out since scope is critical for the anchor to set in the first place.

in a crowded anchorage, I usually set with more scope and then shorten it. In the typical 10 foot depth, i set with 75' and then shorten it up to as short as 50. setting with longer scope insure a good set which will hold well even when shortened.
 
many times i am backing up against a sand bar and only in 8' of water or so (jewfish key, just inside of longboat pass, well protected and 5' of water 10' off of the beach). my idea of 1/2 of actual scope is still 5:1 and i do not want to find out when i am 10' feet from the beach that my anchor went down and fouled up or caught in some grass, especially when the admiral is about to wade our stern anchor into shore. at this point i am almost using my bow anchor as a set of brakes.

that actually brings up a pet peave of mine. why do some people think there stern anchor can be smaller then there bow anchor?????? more times then not i observed the stern anchor holding the entire load of the boat or flotilla of boats!
 
OK! Now I have to get into this! Them’s fightin’ words!

mixman said, “I too have seen the 3:1 scope idiots. "

I resemble that remark!

A reading of all the posts in this thread, indicates to me that there are some real differences in the anchoring criteria considered important, and in the techniques used to achieve the universal desire to stay attached to the bottom overnight, and that the differences in the ideas expressed seem to be somewhat regional in nature.

I read some of Pascal’s posts on subjects like this, because the teacher in him seems to force him to present his argument in an orderly, logical fashion. However, when I read about anchoring in 10’ of water, I think, “That MUST be Low Water”, but it doesn’t really matter, does it? High and Low are only a couple of feet apart on the East Coast of Florida. The NOAA data available to me shows a tide range of 4-8’ today, with 4’ at Miami.

Yzer, in San Francisco Bay, is looking at a tide range of 8’ today at Golden Gate.

Ghost, who boats where I boat, in the PNW, expresses my sediments exactly …

"8:1 !!!

Never would I get the opportunity to put out that much."

Point Atkinson, the reference for my area, indicates a 15’ HW for today, and LW at 2.7’.
Prince Rupert, where I boated this summer, has a HW of 23.5’ and LW at 1.2’ today. Rupert has tides to 25’. One has to anchor here based on the o/n HW level.

In 10’ of water, 8:1 scope requires 80’ of rode out. If I were to anchor, in really shallow water, on the 10 meter contour (32’), with a 25’ tide o/n, I would be in 57’ of water at HW and need 456’ of rode out at 8:1 scope. In 64’ at LW, I would need 712’ out. That ain’t gonna’ happen, boys! There is no way I could stay away from the shoreline rocks with 400 - 700’ of rode out, in most of the anchorages.

My first trip to SE Alaska, I went with 60’ of chain, and 600’ of nylon attached to my 33 lb. Bruce, and never used more than 300’ in 89 o/n anchorages. Now I go with 300’ of nylon, 60’ of chain (all of which goes on the bottom at HW depths), attached to the same Bruce, and rarely use a scope greater than 3:1. I sleep like a baby, ... except for the pee breaks.

The shoreline geography along both coasts of North America is so varied, that different techniques may be applicalble to different goegraphies. A little tolerance, please!

OS

2July17001.jpg

2July17002.jpg
 
Folks should absolutely know the local conditions for tides, currents, average water depth, etc. In the delta where yzer, me and lots of other boaters anchor, the typical depth is 20 ft with a tide swing of 5-7 ft except for the extremes caused by the moon.

I'm a big proponent of using both a bow and stern anchor. If it is windy, I snuggle up into the tules. But my stern anchor prevents the boat from shifting too much with the currents changing from the tide flux. It is also my back up in the rare case my bow anchor breaks free.
 
this is one of the nice things about these forums : you get to learn about practices outside your local area...

this is why in almost every post, i make it a point to give little details like location... anchoring in So Fl is different than in other places because of tides (or lack of), bottom condition, depth, etc... we don't have rocks, we don't have stumps, we dont' have tides... we dont' really need to worry about tide when anchoring or anchors snagging something...

tolerance ? yeah, i agree... but do we have to type a list of exclusions along with every statement we make ? it's pretty obvious that conditions vary ...
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

...
tolerance ? yeah, i agree... but do we have to type a list of exclusions along with every statement we make ? it's pretty obvious that conditions vary ...





Gee, I hope not. There was no intent to offend anyone, but it didn't seem obvious to me that all the posters understood that others reading this thread might be boating and anchoring under very different conditions than their local ones. I hope you didn't miss my tongue-in-cheek approach to this post, Pascal. I guess I should have sprinkled those little smiley faces in the appropriate places. :D

OS
 
"I resemble that remark" was my first clue to your post's tongue-in-cheek approach!
 
I liked the OS comments. There are at least as many local anchoring conditions as there are places to anchor. That's why I like reading about the different gear and styles people use on boats from a variety of areas.

I keep in mind that anchoring for lunch or an afternoon can be less demanding of equipment and technique than anchoring for an overnight or several days on the hook.

Something I wanted to add about Danforth-type anchors and tides. I often read about the possibility of Danforths breaking loose with the 180-degree shifts in current that you will see in tidal zones. That's a legitimate concern but there are often other elements that can prevent this from happening.

If there is a prevailing wind at about 90 degrees to the current direction, it will help keep the boat well within that 180 degree arc and the anchor won't budge. Having some extra chain helps too, because under most conditions more chain helps to limit travel and swing. I get plenty of tidal current action and tend to have prevailing wind most of the time. I also have a boatlength of chain.

Sometimes I'll get very calm wind at slack current and that's when I worry about the boat wandering a 360 degree circle around the anchor. That could cause problems. The anchor swivel will help to avoid twist in the rode, but it may not prevent the anchor from loosening when pulled from the wrong direction. Again, the extra weight of the chain helps me here: under these conditions the boat is more likey to circle around the end of the chain than around the anchor.

If I want to put slack current wandering to a complete end: that's where a stern anchor can come in handy.
 
do not make me put an attorney like disclosure at the end of all of my posts....you know the kind....they go on for paragraphs at the end of an email.

.......please take everything i say with a grain of salt, all of my of my comments are designed to be worthless, everybody should research any topic i speak about on there own, listening to my comments may make you dumber by the minute, reading my comments may make you go blind, thinking about my comments may cause an accident which in turn can lead to blindness, numbness, tingling of all body part, frequent trips to the head, (oh gosh and do not trip on the way to the head that may lead to .............

where i do most of my anchoring tide swing is minimal, maybe two feat total. nowhere near 25'. we are mostly sand with a little bit of very short grass.

i could not imagine having to carry 400' of ground tackle just to anchor for the night, and that only being 3:1....i would need to get me a bigger anchor! i am most
 
quote:

Originally posted by tcijoe

do not make me put an attorney like disclosure at the end of all of my posts....you know the kind....they go on for paragraphs at the end of an email.

.......please take everything i say with a grain of salt, all of my of my comments are designed to be worthless, everybody should research any topic i speak about on there own, listening to my comments may make you dumber by the minute, reading my comments may make you go blind, thinking about my comments may cause an accident which in turn can lead to blindness, numbness, tingling of all body part, frequent trips to the head, (oh gosh and do not trip on the way to the head that may lead to ...........






tcijoe:

May I please have your written permission to copy the above statement and use it at the end of each of my posts (assuming I ever work up the courage to make another one). I will, of course, credit you as being the originator and copyright holder of the statement ( I wouldn't have been able to come up with any near as brilliant.) :D

OS
 
Thanks OS for the laugh. From a guy here in the PNW any way.

Some spots I visit the hook is let go in over 300 feet of water. Just off a steep shore line. I let out 150 feet chain and then back into the bottom till the hook makes contact. Stern tie off the boat in the 50 to 75 foot depth range. Make it all tite with two lines from the boat to shore. I can then play the shore lines against the winch to ensure a good hook up if I need but thats been rare. I have taken the stern lines to shore from Invader cause the beach so to speak drops off so fast.

Not the norm any way.
 
quote:

Originally posted by oldfishboat

... Some spots I visit the hook is let go in over 300 feet of water...





Willy, I had never experienced that until a couple of summers ago. We were pottzing around in the Burdwood Group and came across 3 boatloads of friends rafted together in a U-shaped Cove just off the main channel. The middle boat had the anchor out and the 2 outer boats were stern tied to each side of the shore. They invited us to raft up, as it was nearing lunchtime, and assuring me they had no intention of staying the night. It was also my birthday, so I asked if I could bring along a bottle of wine. As I approached the raft-up I checked the sounder and it read 357'! After tying up, I was amazed to see the sounder at 50-60', and opening the wine, I asked how much rode was out. The answer was, "All of it! Over 300'".
Wouldn't ya' know, the wind came up, the tide hit bottom, the flood current from Tribune Channel started running through the cove, the four of us pivoted about the upwind boat, and our boat, on the downwind side started moving towards the beach at an increasing rate.

Willy, you woulda' laughed until you had new holes in a fresh pair o' socks, if you had seen me quaff my wine, wipe my chin, leap to my boat, fire up, untie it, run to Waddington Bay, run it into the mud, chuck the Bruce over the bow, and pour myself a big glass of pain killer to stop the shakes. Never again! I like flat bottoms on everything but nice ladies.:D

OS

Edit: I shoulda' put a smiley man after that last sentence, shouldn't I? Done.
 
Back
Top