My Deviant Compass

Trying to answer some of your questions- yes, I do have Chapmans (I should use it more than I do).
Only equipment is my Chartplotter, that is set to display COG (magnetic)- no autopilot, and my boat compass.
The closest speaker is at least 4' horiz. distance and 3' below compass plane on dashboard. So I don't believe the speakers are any influence.
I was observing these differences while in the (Merrimack)river, at places where it's fairly wide with minimal effect of wind or current. If you assume for the moment, that there is no wind/current effect, the GPS(chartplotter) COG (magnetic)= (compass course to steer[actual compass reading])+ (compass deviation). For a given COG if deviation was 0*, COG(M)= CTS(M)

If you assume a 3* error, over a 10 nm leg, that would give you a 0.5 nm cross track error.

I would imagine the compass really needs to be properly aligned (Lubbers Line) first, before any sort of deviation table is prepared.

SteveG- sounds like a plan. The deviant owner is already factored in :-)

Again, some great feedback folks!
Jack
 
jack this simplifies things alot. if your plotter is not fitted with a heading sensor and can only display your COG and not the heading then the conflict is between the magnetic compass and the COG. a deviation that big is not normal and a correction chart is not the answer. you are picking up either a large metal object or magnetic field somewhere near your compass. try pulling the compass from its mounts and moving it by hand to anther location on the boat and see if the problem goes away. assuming it does, you just have to either find the source of the interferance or purchase a compass that has correction magnets in it that will allow you to offset the interferance
 
To some degree it IS the speaker. To some degree it is probably an alignment error (somewhat detectable bý eyeballing - for a large error. Sight across the card over two reciprocals and your bow cleat), to some degree it's a compensation issue. Your compass has BIC magnets - not an entirely big deal to adjust, unless you want zero error on every point (actually, every 15 degrees, little more than a point).

But the most salient point to be made is that some variance between COG and magnetic compass heading is to be expected. 30 degrees is a lot, and I think it's a composite error.Have to go fume about a 50 dllar parking ticket while I was out on the inflatable with the family for a while, then I'll be back and explain further what I mean.
 
In the fwiw department:

When my shiny, clean new boat was delivered, the compass was clearly whacked out. After going through a through diagnosis ( on my part ) the conclusion was that the installers attempted to screw the compass down by screwing the adjustment screw. Needless to say, there was much error in the compass.

The cure, for me, was to remove the compass from the boat. Place it on a wooden board in the center of the parking lot ( away from all metal ), and getting a good visual on true North, then ( following the compass mfgr's directions) proceeded to correct the compass, using the adjustment screw. It took about 10 minutes to "true the compass". Then I replaced the compass on the boat, being careful of alignment.

Result: Compass was close enough ( for my use ) on all headings. Max error was about 1.5 degrees, which is about equal to this helmsman's skill at steering a straight course ;). Considering the max leg distance I might travel, this was well within needed accuracy.

You may wish to consider this...

--

Definition: "clearly whacked out". A technical term. Synonym of FUBAR and MUNGE. Roughly equivalent to "non-functional".
 
I had a problem with a Riche 5" compass when I first purchased my sailboat years ago. No matter where the boat was pointed, there was a significant compass error.

I removed the compass from the boat, put it onto the dock with no magnetic materials nearby. I slowly rotated the compass and you could see the pointer varying all over the place. Next I replaced the compass on the boat and pointed the boat to a reference point followed by rotating the compass and making adjustments. Took about an hour but I got it down to +/- 2 degrees. I never had a problem after that.

Somebody mentioned that all new compasses require calibration. Well maybe not. Riche's compasses without the compensation magnetics seem to be right on the mark.

Foggy
 
As far as I know just about all new compasses have the compensation magnets set at zero. Unfortunately any tampering can induce a considerable error. The only way to know is to check.
 
I went to the boat this afternoon to do some checking. I opened the hinged access panel in the cabin that exposes all the switches on the dash board. It also shows the underside of the compass. To my surprise, less than 6" from the compass is this 1" diameter cable harness running fore/aft on the port side of the compass. It was all wrapped up but seems to be the cabin wiring that runs on top of the headliner toward the front of the boat. There's not much slack in that cable, but it would be interesting to have someone move that harness around as another person is watching the compass.

If this is the culprit, I'm not sure what can be done to relocate that harness. I suspect it's DC power for cabin lighting and switches. Can't believe Sea Ray would do something like that, unless the compass was installed later.
Jack
 
Try wrapping some foil temporarily around the wire and ground the foil, see if it makes a difference. If it does, there are metal shieldings that can be placed over the wire to minimize the effects.
 
Most boats have wiring, electronics & gauges in unfortunate proximity to compass installations. Much of the time it really can't be helped but as in your case perhaps a lot could have been better planned for minimal compass influence . Most compasses even have wiring for backlights. Sometimes twisting pairs of wires or using a grounded shield can help reduce influence I believe, but generally the best we can do is get the compass compensated for least deviation when the usual circuits are activated as when cruising, and as you intend , have a deviation table/card at hand for a magnetic heading reality check.

BTW, if the speaker you refer to is a (not magnetically-shielded type) stereo speaker, I'd guess it's conceivable that it could have influence that far away. Magnets on boats are the worst enemies of compasses. If just a little internal VHF spkr, likely no prob at that distance unless you have a spkr/mic or remote vhf spkr hung closer. Sometimes A/P hydraulic pumps are mounted inside the dash near the gauges too,... mine is (magnets in elct. motors.) Watch where you put the cell phone.
 
Thanks Sandy. I'm going to try shielding & grounding that cable harness, make sure the backlight feed for the compass is twisted and then proceed to create my deviation table.

Everyone's inputs have been quite helpful. Much appreciated.
Jack
 
only if current is flowing will the magnetic field affect your compass. You should be able to see the needle move even while at the dock when you switch those circuits on and off if they are the culprits.
 
Jack, we can try it Monday night if you want...
 
Steve- good. See you Monday afternoon. We'll give it a few tests.
Jack
 
Steve & Jack, Remember- Don't remove more than 1/2 a beer per course leg or you may soon be chasing your tail.
 
Sandy- you're very perceptive! And wise to us- :-)
Luckily, we'll be navigating to the 'test' area via IFR (I Follow Rivers).

Jack
 
After 6 beers (total between Steve and I) and safely tied up back at the dock, we performed some highly sophisticated tests....
Steve jiggled the harness and I watched the compass. It did not blink. And while underway, again, just doing spot comparisons at different GPS headings, the compass was at least 20* different and varied at least +/- 10* from this as boat course changed. So it's time to take it apart and see if there are any adjustment magnets and get a professional to look at it.

Steve- great trip today and thanks again for the 'refreshments'!!!

Jack
 
you should have tried turning stuff on and off.
 
Where do you get/find/locate the plastic screwdriver?

RWS
 
We did try turning lights on/off, including the compass backlight. There was no movement.
RWS- I have not attempted anything with the compass yet. I just realized that when I installed my tank watch system a few seasons ago, the calibration screwdriver was plastic. I'll probably go far enough to remove it and see if it has correcting magnets.

Jack
 
Back
Top